Is he shooter

bearpaws · Sep 26, 2005

I have been watching this buck for the last 3 years this year
he has some trash and is looking pretty good. He has always been a big four with good backs and weak fronts but this year he
has some trash. Should I take him this or wait another year and see if he grows. What do you think he scores?

Hornseeker · Sep 26, 2005

Usually!

MuleyObsessions · Sep 26, 2005

If it were me I would definitely take him that is a nice looking deer.

MadBowHunter · Sep 26, 2005

If you are worried about hunting pressure from others I'd take him, but if he receives little, if any, pressure I'd be inclined to wait another year. I am new to mule deer hunting but passed on a lot of nice bucks and took my first Muley this year with my bow and he is a "30-incher" with garbage. (See my posting "My First Mulie - Amen" in this forum for my pics) I have found an area in Colorado that receives little to no hunting pressure and has some great bucks like that one and better. Ultimately it's up to you. Good Luck.

Are you shooting bow or rifle?

Zigga · Sep 26, 2005

Wait til next year.

Muleyslyr · Sep 26, 2005

Who cares what he scores.....He's unique! I would WAY rather have a unique lookin' buck on my wall than a 170" typical 4pt. I say take him if you get the chance.

BigChicken · Sep 26, 2005

Do the gene pool a favor - take him out. He really is a nice buck though, a buck like that can't be ignored.

Roy · Sep 26, 2005

If it were a general open season public land hunt - I'd pop him in a heartbeat. However if you are in a draw area and want a buck that will score then don't.
ROY

need2hunt · Sep 26, 2005

LAST EDITED ON Sep-26-05 AT 04:24PM (MST)[p]If it were me i'd take him and enjoy some steaks!!! You don't find many bucks with that much character....not to mention that height...I think he looks cool.

spotit1st · Sep 26, 2005

Just ask yourself would I be proud to have this buck hanging on my wall, I think hes unique but without seeing him first hand I wouldn't be able to tell you yes or no, from the pics I would more than likely put him down! Good Luck deciding, post some pics if you decide that hes good enough for your wall!!

intimidater37 · Sep 26, 2005

bang!!!!

bobcatbess · Sep 26, 2005

WELL

I CAN TELL YOU DON'T LIVE IN UTARD!!!

IF YOU DID IT WOULD BE LIKE POST # 10,BANG TWO YEARS AGO!!!

THE BUCK IS WAY BETTER THAN THE NOMAD BUCK!!!

OPTION # 1 YOU CAN SEND ME THE COORDINATES & WAIT TO SEE IF HE'S STILL AROUND NEXT YEAR,HE,HE!!!

OPTION # 2 I DOUGHT THE BUCK WILL EVER BE REAL BIG HORNED BUT IF YOU THINK HE'LL STILL BE AROUND NEXT YEAR I'D SHOOT THE FOUR POINT TO THE RIGHT & CHECK THIS BUCK OUT NEXT YEAR!!!

I'D PICK OPTION # 1 IF I WERE YOU!!!

THE ONLY bobcat WONDERING WHERE THE HELL THIS MIGHT BE??? A BUCK THAT LIVES SEVERAL YEARS,NA, THAT AIN'T UTARD!!!

mtmuley · Sep 26, 2005

What about the one to the right? Have you seen him lately since the growth has stopped? mtmuley

PDub · Sep 27, 2005

I'm not sure if i would or not...but that's a question you're going to have to answer for yourself. Lots of good feed back here...goo dluck on deciding what to do!

P-DUB...Scott