The Ed Broder Buck Story

kilowatt · Jan 8, 2006

Picked up at the book store today the latest issue of Hunting Illustrated's Special Winter Issue 2005/2006.

Great reading about this buck and what that Broder Family is doing to each other over the sale.
Also inside is a Article by Arnold Sandoval and it is about one of our own MMer members D13er and his hunt last year down in Mexico for his great Coues Buck. Congrats to you Jef.

Brian

MichaelJ · Jan 8, 2006

congrats guys!!

Michael~All Gods creatures welcome... right next to the mashed potatoes and gravy.

Lien2 · Jan 9, 2006

Read D13er article this weekend, and stopped last night at the Broder buck article. I'll hit that one tonight.
Congrats again D13er on that monster coues, looks and sounds like you guys had a great time!!!

Lien2

HunterHarry · Jan 9, 2006

Much like a sexy woman, any wonder this rack can cause family problems???

Chef · Jan 9, 2006

That thing is unbelievable.

HH, you have to post up the other racks from that trip too!

Chef
"I Love Animals...They're Delicious!"

robinh00d · Jan 9, 2006

gotta love those monster alberta bucks
eh?

NMHUNTNUTT1 · Jan 9, 2006

PICKED UP A COPY AT WALLY WORLD YESTERDAY .I really like that mag , its right there with Trophy Hunter and Eastmans....Some big mamer jammers in every issue too...NM

clyde · Jan 9, 2006

Wow!!!!!!!

eelgrass · Jan 9, 2006

They can't sell it. It looks like HH owns it now!

I'll have to pick up a copy.

Steve

257Tony · Jan 9, 2006

Just in case somebody doesnt know, thats the Worlds Record. 355 2/8ths, 1926. Not bad for such an old buck.....

HunterHarry · Jan 9, 2006

Naw, It ain't mine.
I just got to pose with it, but it is the original.
HH

clyde · Jan 9, 2006

Can I hold it?

cheeseheadinOHIO · Jan 9, 2006

That's sick!!

MichaelJ · Jan 9, 2006

Holy HELL! I'd seen pics, but not like that!

Michael~All Gods creatures welcome... right next to the mashed potatoes and gravy.

Longun · Jan 10, 2006

So, has anybody heard what the outcome was at the court hearing on December 1 2005?

eelgrass · Jan 10, 2006

I want to hold it too! Maybe even fondle it a little! HunterHarry, you're a lucky guy. I would be smiling just the way you are.

Steve

fowlguy · Jan 12, 2006

the family got the deer back, put it up for auction and the same guy that won it before got it again for about the same price. A lot to do over nothing

bcmulie · Jan 17, 2006

I read the article in Hunting Illustrated yesterday, and looked up the Court of Appeal decision this morning. Don Broder's appeal relating to the estate's entitlement to the Broder Buck was dismissed. His appeal relating to the finding of civil contempt was allowed, on the basis that it was impossible for him to comply with the order to deliver the Broder Buck (the order he had been found in contempt of) because it was not in his possession. The Court of Appeal ordered that Don Broder pay costs in the amount of $28,500.

Hunting Illustrated routinely contains photos of some fantastic trophies, but I can't say that I'm terribly impressed with the article on the Broder Buck. In my view it does not paint an objective and accurate picture of what has actually gone on. That's just my personal opinion, though.