KIRT DARNER STORY

H

huntinco

Guest
KIRT DARNER STORY

LAST EDITED ON Feb-07-06 AT 11:18AM (MST)[p]
Found this on Rich LaRocco's site. Personaly I don't know one thing about Kirt Darner.



Many of you might know that I wrote both of Kirt Darner's books in the early '80s. Some of you might know that shortly afterward evidence came into my hands that he had not killed one of his Boone and Crockett mule deer, and I turned that evidence over to Jack Reneau of the Boone and Crockett Club, which later ruled against Darner.

This is a long and sorry story, and I've never written it down until now though I've been happy to share it with people who have asked. At this point, before you continue, perhaps you should click on the headline to read the latest chapter in this saga before you continue from the beginning.
http://www.wildlife.state.nm.us/publications/press_releases/documents/0202indictments.htm

I first found out about Darner when I was senior editor at Outdoor Life Magazine (yes, I worked in Manhattan), and I was assigned to edit an article that my friend Jim Zumbo had written about the man. Darner was supposedly the most successful trophy mule deer hunter of all time and had seven bucks in the Boone and Crockett Club's record book.

I also found an article that been written by Doug Knight in Field and Stream magazine in the late '60s or early '70s. The article featured a hunt that Knight had enjoyed with Darner and another young friend in a New Mexico wilderness area, where Knight reported seeing some great bucks and where Darner and his friend both killed big deer.

Later, I left New York to return to the wild and free and sunny West and settled in Cache Valley, Utah. Clair Conley, editor-in-chief of Outdoor Life, asked me to stay with the magazine as Western field editor. I turned him down because the Western field editor of the time was my friend Dwight Schuh, who is now editor of Bowhunting Magazine. Clair said he was firing Dwight whether I took the job or not, and so I reluctantly agreed. If I had to make that decision over again, I would have turned down the job a second time, but sometimes in life you learn the hard way, and when you're hardheaded, that's how you tend to learn all your big lessons.

And that is the case with the Darner story.

(this article by Hunts.Net President Rich LaRocco will be continued with photographs next week)
www.hunts.net
 
RE: KIRT DARNER STORY

LAST EDITED ON Feb-07-06 AT 11:10AM (MST)[p]It should be interesting to finally here the real story
Justin
 
RE: KIRT DARNER STORY

say it isn't so joe, what a shocker, sounds insain man, but the criminal mind is... he obviously got caught with his hands in the cookie jar 'eh, he may have skirted the first time but not this one, unless he has a really slick lawyer.

I for one was one of the people who had given him the benefit of the doubt, but now what can you say...I'm bumed way bumed, he may have taken some of those monsters but they just don't mean a thing with out integraty...SAD!!!!
 
RE: KIRT DARNER STORY

Look forward to the rest of the story, its too bad though.....that guy helped me get the bug for big muleys.
 
RE: KIRT DARNER STORY

Regardless of his guilt, Darners book "How to hunt big mule deer" is still a great book with some very vital information about hunting big muleys. It's just too bad he, himself didn't always use his own written tactics to gather his collection. It is an excellent book though, and right now my 15 year old son is reading my copy of it.
I look forward to reading more about this topic.
 
RE: KIRT DARNER STORY

From the news release:

"They are accused of illegally moving as many as four state-owned elk from the Lobo Canyon Ranch to the Pancho Peaks ranch and game park in southeastern New Mexico in 2002."

This is one of the reasons elk farms should be illegal in every state in the country!
 
RE: KIRT DARNER STORY

The story of the mule deer that would be king began in 1963 when an avid mule-deer hunter named Lee Spurgeon invited a young man named Kirt Darner on a mule-deer hunt in Colorado's La Plata County. Spurgeon and Darner, who both lived in Albuquerque, New Mexico, had become acquainted when both were residents of Iowa. Although Darner was unable to go on the hunt, he later stopped by Spurgeon's house.

"I found this buck during a blinding snowstorm," Spurgeon said. "I just hope the meat is good."
When Darner looked at the buck, all thoughts of meat vanished. Darner, for anyone unfamiliar with his history, once had thirteen mule deer listed in the Boone and Crockett record book-more than anyone else. After run-ins with the club over the legitimacy and eligibility of a few of his trophies, Darner withdrew all of them from the book in protest. Regardless of his troubles, Darner knows big mule deer-and Spurgeon's was a
veritable monster.

"I nagged Lee about measuring it, but he'd just say, 'I don't care about that stuff,'" Darner said.
More than thirty years passed. Then, several years ago, Spurgeon suffered a debilitating stroke. Darner was overwhelmed when Spurgeon's family told him Spurgeon wanted him to have both the buck's rack and the 7mm Ackley rifle he had used to bag it. Not long afterward, Spurgeon died.

For a time, the Spurgeon buck appeared to be on the fast track to becoming Boone and Crockett's record typical mule-deer buck. People who have seen this rack agree that the title rightfully belongs to this great 5x5, with its 29 2/8-inch spread and only 3% points of deductions. Had it been certified, Spurgeon's buck would have roared into first place with a score of 229%, or 3 3/8 points more than the score of the current champion Burris buck.

Unfortunately, Spurgeon's great buck was not certified, nor is it likely to be due to its ownership by Kirt Darner. Still, the buck that would be king may someday reign supreme. When that will happen, though, is anybody's guess.-Kathy Etling
Copyright Sports Afield, Inc. Feb/Mar 2004

Provided by ProQuest Information and Learning Company. All rights Reserved
 
RE: KIRT DARNER STORY

People here have seen me go negative when Kirt Darner's name is mentioned.
I bought his book when it first hit the market.
I don't know him personally.
I HAVE been told by some highly respected authorities in the Monster Muley fanatic community that,
1.He is obsessed with Monster Muleys.
2.He is an extremley good hunter.
3.He is extremeley knowledgeble about trophy Muleys.
4.He has a charming personality, Is basicly a friendly guy that will take the time to talk to the average Joe.
5 He has taken quite a few MONSTER bucks.
6.He did not take ALL the bucks that he claims to have taken.
I have never heard any specifics about him poaching a particular buck, but with these latest charges, his credibility is tarnished beyond repair in my opinion.
It is a real shame that we as strangers are conversing about a fellow hunters misfortune, but Kirt Darner was a celebrity, and unfortunatley for him he is in the limelight, good or bad.
I wish he could have been the legend that he had the potential to be, and if innocent, I will be the first to eat crow.
I would gladly do that, rather than see a man's life and his lifelong passion flushed down the toilet.
I wish he could come on this site and field questions.
The whole saga is regrettable.
HH
 
RE: KIRT DARNER STORY

HH?..
The reason I posted this is because this topic is always popping up and hopefully this would shed some fact full light on the subject and maybe put the topic to rest
 
RE: KIRT DARNER STORY

Huntinco I hope Rich tells the whole story about the Boxholder buck the Ram and all as he related too me many years ago.Not everyone is gonna still think the fishhook is the best thing since sliced bread. Tell Rich hello for me when you see him. Steve M.
 
RE: KIRT DARNER STORY

I think his book is a pretty good read. I always had questions concerning the amount of pictures of mounts compared to field photos, but I just figured it was due to the time period. The elk poaching thing, I written off as a heat of the moment thing. Now, I have some serious doubts. The stolen sheep heads are the most disgusting. If he's guilty, he's plain robbing fellow sportsman of their trophy of a lifetime.

I was dreaming the other day that I harvested the new B&C typical mule deer. If I did not sell the trophy, would I have to hire security to keep it safe? Would my taxidermist have to hire security as well? The truth is: Yes. And it's disgusting.
 
RE: KIRT DARNER STORY

he'll never be able to explain away the sheep horns...guilty as sin...receiving stolen property..hmmmm..

I just hope the guy who shot the ram will get 'em back soon enough...
 

Click-a-Pic ... Details & Bigger Photos
Back
Top Bottom