The only person that can ever answer the question "is it a shooter" is the one posing the question. Sure, it may help to validate your personal decision to hear what others think of your scouted bull, but it really doesn't matter what others would shoot. It all comes down to what have you scouted out. How would you feel on day 6 or 7 if you had passed that bull on day 1 and not seen anything close to him? What do you have on your wall now? What is your goal? Would tag soup taste great to you if you have the personal satisfaction that you could have taken lesser bulls but held strong to your conviction? As for score, I have no idea other than he's big enough for me based on my goals and what's on my wall.