Score these Bucks

[bigoltom]

The one on the left is a 4 x 4 and the one on the right is a 4 x ???. Sorry the pic isn't that great but it is all I got. What do you guys think?

 

[muleybull]

Bigoltom, you out hiding from work again. Im gonna say 110 on the left and 111 on the right.

Is that ethical?

 

[bigoltom]

Muleybull-
Wrong as usual, keep trying and one day you will get it right!

 

[life2extreme]

Shoot one and then you can tape that one and guesstamate the other.

Aim Center Mass

 

[WAstickslinger]

Shoot the one on the left this year. He looks a few years older. The one on the right will be a stud next year. Then put a tape on both of them while they are on the ground. Im not a good in the field scorer. sorry??????

 

[muleybull]

Im not a very good in the field scorer either, I better at scoring them on the ground.

Is that ethical?

 

[muleybull]

Okay, heres my guess.

The one on the left Im thinking, (if his right horn thats hidden is as good as his left) low 180's.

Now the buck on the right has extras on his right side. Hes not very wide, I think 24 to 26 wide at best, but a few extra scorable points with a good frame. I think he will gross in the low to mid 190's. But gross is all that counts anyway. Give him 2 years and you'll break the 200 mark I bet.

You got GPS coordinates to these deer?

Is that ethical?

 

[PJHntr]

Left-165, Right-180

 

[ScentHound]

Both in the 180s... give or take a couple

 

[manny15]

both shooters but I'd shoot the one on the right, left 170ish right 180ish

 

[Califelkslayer]

I agree the buck on the right is bigger, heavier. Rather have him on my wall. Horns are mingled between the 2 but I'll guess the right hand buck scores about 185" and right @ 27"s wide. The left hand buck looks older in the body and face but I don't think he's as good.

 

[groundhog]

They are both good deer. The buck on the right looks like it might push the 180 mark. Is it my imagination or does the buck on the right have a hole tore open in his chest? Looks like he ran into a barbed wire fence or something.

 

[southy10]

Great bucks left is a 170 buck and the right is a 180 buck I would kill both the right one more then the left .....

 

[bigoltom]

Groundhog-
There is no hole in his chest, I got just a short clip of video of these deer in the field so I played it when I got home and paused it on the tv screen so I could take this picture to post it. I think the flash from the camera just caught it funny.

 

[muleybull]

Okay, we can put this to rest. I was with bigoltom when he got these pics, we were scouting for my hunt.

I shot the one on the left opening morning. He scored 182 and some change. I watched the one on the right through my scope for about 15-20 minutes after I killed mine. I think hes a little better than the picture lets on.

Yes, I think I shot the smaller of the 2 so I'm sticking with my low to mid 190's guess with the buck on the right.

P.S., the buck on the left was only 23 1/2" wide, good mass and long points.

Is that ethical?

 

[sonofthesouth]

Pics?

Son

 

[gilamonster8]

Pics are tough gut im going to say shooter shooter

 

[overton]

Really rusty since I didn't see a mature muley this year but my guess would be keepers. PM me a map please.


Ransom

 

[Roy]

Uhhh - all I can tell is that the one on the right would look good over the mantle and there's a spot for the other one above the sofa!

UTROY
Proverbs 21:19 (why I hunt!)

 

[ICHABOD]

Sounds like the one on the left scores 180 and some change...
but the one on the right won the game...

------------------------------------------------------
By the way,
I live in UT.
There are a lot of UTARDS that live here.
I have also seen quite a few WYOMORONS, NEVADUHNS, COLORADORKS, ID-IOTS and AIRHEADZONANS in my travels.