Big vs Monster Bull Elk Difference????????

Hiker of the Woods

Active Member
Messages
623
I have a few questions for those with experience hunting and/or scouting bulls in the 340-360 class and 370+ class range. The main reason for this topic is not to ask for locations of 340+ bulls but to gain knowledge, tips, tricks, advice or whatever in hunting large bulls to help out my friend who will be drawing the Wenaha archery branch bull tag this year. Does anyone notice any different behaviors between 340-360 class vs 370+ bulls? What about flat Nation Forest land vs big deep and steep Wilderness areas? Any behavior or locations differences between both groups pre-rut vs rut? Do you hunt 340-360class vs 370+ bulls differently? PM?s are welcome.

Here are some of my thoughts and ways we hunt. Please feel free to throw out any advice if you think it would help in harvesting a 340+ bull. Dream would be to get a 370+ bull.

Big old bulls are unique and you have to adjust your hunting accordingly to hunt them. Besides being older, they're wiser, heavier, more mellow, slower, and much more deliberate in their actions. Herd bulls won't always be the largest antlered bull in the area. The fact that they got 5, 6, 7+ years-old is an indication that they found a safe way to exist and avoid hunters and predators.

Every day should be spent hiking into the locations where we plan to glass or listen to elk without letting them know our presence before daylight. We hunt till dark before hiking back to camp to take advantage of every minute of shooting light.

I have noticed most bright nights with half a moon or more will be from September 1-15th. Most dark nights with 24% or less moon will be from September 18-24th. New moon is September 23rd. Would the moon phase play any role in when you would put in for your vacation time if you could not hunt the entire archery season?

I have always had better luck with elk being active during daylight when there is no or little moon light at night. There would still be good daytime activity if there was thick cloud cover even during a full moon. The problem I see with no or little moon the last week of archery season this year would be that the big bulls would have cows with them that could ruin a stalk or make it extremely hard to call in. On the other hand it would make for a very exciting season with lots of daylight activity and encounters.

My little experience hunting the Wenaha Wilderness is that the elk will use the tops of ridges say the first half of season. This could be because of food, flat terrain, and little to no human pressure. As season goes on they tend to come up in elevation less and start spending more time in the bottom of the canyons/drainages. This could be from food source getting burned out on top, more cover at the bottom, cooler temps at bottom, flat terrain for rut, etc. Has anyone else noticed this? Would you expect to not be able to glass bulls in the wilderness as much come later in season and have to go mainly by sound?

We will most likely glass, listen, and make silent stalks on bulls for the majority of the time. Calling will consist of cow, calf, with occasional spike/small bull bugle with callers 50+ yards behind hunter. Things like making noise like a herd is casually walking around, raking of trees, or walking away from bull while calling may be used in certain situations. Our goal is not to intimidate herd or large bulls with bugles they have never heard before. I believe most bulls have a pretty good idea about who his competition is in the area. Big bulls have individually recognizable voices just like we as human do.

I think a key to successfully put a tag on a 340+ class bull is patience and knowing when not to hunt. This may mean backing out and entering area where bull is from different angle because of wind conditions or cover. It may mean even waiting to the next day for the bull to be in the right stalking location or wind conditions.

One thing that is being considered is only having one caller go with hunter and the other go off to try and locate a large bull in a different area.

Any help or ideas are appreciated.
 
All else being equal.......A big bull is the one you shot and a monster is the one I shot lol. Good luck hunting to all.
 
The 11 year old bull I shot in the south cache unit didn't break 350. He was a wise old bull. He would be in the trees before it got light and stay there until it was dark again. I wanted a bigger bull, but I couldn't locate another bull that would stay put. They kept moving/getting pushed so much I couldn't keep track of them. I was kinda hoping that the guy I sent in the direction of the bull would get him. He was more of a shooter than a hunter. So I went and shot him. I think I had the advantage because I have archery hunted most of my life and this was the rifle hunt. Just like most of my archey hunts, he stopped with his vitals behind the tree. This was my first neck shot and the fastest I have seen an animal go down in one shot. Even when I don't have a tag, I still love getting to see them up close. I don't care much for the pain in my ears when they bugle within 50 yards, but it is worth it.







________________________________________
I'm not one for telling my grandson how big of turd I had to pinch off from having to eat so much meat. I want to give him the trophies that hang from my wall and tell him the unforgettable experience that came with each and every one.
 
A little more information about us and the hunt.

This hunt takes place in Oregon and we are all residents of Oregon. This is a once-in-a-lifetime tag for residents if you are lucky. Residents new to hunting would have to wait over 100 years before drawing this tag and it is known for monster bulls. My friend is perfectly happy with going home with tag still in pocket if he can't at least put it on a 340+ bull which I think we can do from experience in this unit. I just don't have that much experience really keeping track and learning the behavior of old bulls in the 370+ range. I helped another guy on this hunt several years ago that passed up three 340 class bulls in one week but then ended up harvested a 320 class bull by the end of his hunt. Just trying to pick up some tips from people who have experience and knowledge how old 370+ bull act pre-rut and during the rut(archery season).
 
You are over thinking it. Big bulls will behave like elk. Some will be responsive to calls, some will be quite, some will run away if they have cows, some will hide in deep dark canyons, some will be off the side of the road, some will water regularly, some will move 10-20 miles looking for cows, some will figure out sooner than others that hunting season is here, some will be stupid and walk right into your arrow. Get the point?

Elk behave like elk they are easier to call early, they rut at night, moon phases play big roll, later in rut they herd up and protect their cows from other bulls, some fight, some lose and are pissed, some will look for revenge, older bulls will 80% have cows so more ears more eyes.

Residents of all states draw OIL elk hunts, units, terrain, temps, moon phases, all of these factors make elk do what elk do..... Survive.

Go hunt and don't pass on mature bull that you would kill on the last day. Hunt hard and smart, glass long hours looking for the big boys and hunt their bedrooms and you will figure out their behaviors. Out!
 
Broomer just said it all, as far as I'm concerned. I've drawn, or had friends draw, a number of OIL type tags over the years in various states including Utah, Nevada, Arizona and New Mexico and I've never worried about it even 20% as much as you are. We've always done fine just by hunting the bulls the same way we hunt them everywhere else, and yes, we've killed some nice bulls the first time we ever set foot in a given unit.

Go hunting, have a great time and kill a nice bull. Be happy with him and don't get too hung up on how many inches he measures. Focus way more on the quality of the experience, and chances are good that the quality of the bull will take care of itself.
 
I have worked in and helped another friend hunt this unit in the past. Have a fun experience in this beautiful country with bulls bugling like crazy will not be hard to do. Trying to get a 340 or 350+ bull within bow range will take some hard work.

>Broomer just said it all, as
>far as I'm concerned.
>I've drawn, or had friends
>draw, a number of OIL
>type tags over the years
>in various states including Utah,
>Nevada, Arizona and New Mexico
>and I've never worried about
>it even 20% as much
>as you are. We've
>always done fine just by
>hunting the bulls the same
>way we hunt them everywhere
>else, and yes, we've killed
>some nice bulls the first
>time we ever set foot
>in a given unit.
>
>Go hunting, have a great time
>and kill a nice bull.
> Be happy with him
>and don't get too hung
>up on how many inches
>he measures. Focus way
>more on the quality of
>the experience, and chances are
>good that the quality of
>the bull will take care
>of itself.
 

Click-a-Pic ... Details & Bigger Photos
Back
Top Bottom