What is a respectable buck today?

blazingsaddle

Active Member
Messages
546
I am wondering what others think a respectable or "trophy" buck is today on a general season hunt in Utah?
I believe the "trophy" is in the eye of the beholder, and of corse a monster is a monster, and a few get dug up every year, but on average, what in your mind is a respectable buck for GS in Utah?
I think just about any 4x4 deserves a tip of the hat.
 
23" to 26" little mass 6"-8" tine length scores 130's to a high 140's.
Now what everyone sees when scouting is a 180 class with tons of mass and stickers all over and he's a 30" if he a dime.
 
If you can find a 2 year old or older deer with a 18-22 inch frame on the general season you better be shooting because some other Utard will shoot over your head and kill him if you don't..





Archery is a year round commitment!!
 
I can't speak to the Utah deer, but, with work, we can find deer a little older and larger than that.
 
I think it had better be at least an 8x8. 8" tall x 8" wide.


Life's journey is not to arrive at the grave in a well preserved body, but to skid in sideways totally worn out shouting HOLY SH!T WHAT A RIDE!!!
 
What about a 5 x 3? Is that as good as a 4 x 4?


Life's journey is not to arrive at the grave in a well preserved body, but to skid in sideways totally worn out shouting HOLY SH!T WHAT A RIDE!!!
 
Here is mine from last year. Northern region public land.



4821302f4fed2970.jpg
 
I'm with gator, anything around 140" or better on a public Utah hunt is doing good.

Dang nice buck Tony, you did good on that one!!
160" ish??









Skull Krazy
"No Bones About It"
 
Yes. Great buck for general season in Utah, and finally, someone who's smiling in their pic and not looking like grandma just died.
 
LAST EDITED ON May-07-08 AT 10:29AM (MST)[p]Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. Respectable? Some people think politicians are respectable, doesn't mean they are. I shot a 320s bull in the Uintas and people ask why I shot such a small bull in Utah. Respectable is whatever you think it is.

Whatever makes you feel happy should be respectable. If you are proud to show it to someone then it is respectable. Some guys are proud to show off a 2 year old 2x3, while others are ashamed to admit they shot a five year old 160s buck. I guess to me it is more than a number.

These Utah general season threads are somewhat funny. The largest buck killed in Utah last year came off a general season unit. The governor's tag has been filled many times with a buck from the general season units. There are numerous "respectable" bucks and some great large, mature bucks killed off of Utah's public general season units every year. The fact that everyone doesn't kill giants every year is what makes those that giant bucks so special.

Tony, that is a respectable buck. Nicely done, including the great photo.

-------------------------
www.sagebasin.com
-------------------------
 
I think the effort that went into it counts. I have more respect for the N. Utah 24" 4x4 than I do the guy who pays thousands of dollars to shoot out of the window of a truck opening morning and get a 30" buck.

My proudest deer is the one I worked the hardest for.

I also take into account the age of the deer. A spindly 26" buck that is 9 years old deserves some serious respect; he evaded a lot of hunters and predators throughout his life, and was probably bigger just a few seasons ago, but survived anyway. To me, the 9 year old buck is more of a trophy than a 28" 4 year old with great genetics and a great growing season behind him. Chances of that 4 year old making it another 5 seasons is pretty slim.

Grizzly
 
Respectable in my opinion comes with the effort made. We'd all like to shot a 140-170 class buck but those kind of bucks don't reside along side the road in most general season units. My complaint is the guys who don't try to harvest something more mature and end up shooting the yearly bucks along side the road. Or that try hard and compromise in the end. How many times have you heard someone say with discust in their voice, "I don't know why I even shot it!?!" Every year I see lots of yearing bucks that if we would let them go a year they might be that 18-22 inch 4x4 next season, a little wiser a little older and a lot harder to harvest and more would live into future seasons to become what we all dream of, a big, mature, massive buck! Instead some of you think you can't go home empty handed and so you shoot. I know some of you will say you need the meat! But really how much meat can you get off a yearly buck. Anyone ever figure the price/pound? It's good to eat don't get me wrong, but we ought to controll ourselves and let them live!
 
ledoux-

Welcome to MM, that's a fantastic general area buck, better than even some private or LE units produce, congrat's!!





Skull Krazy
"No Bones About It"
 
>My buck last year . Northern
>Utah public land, they are
>there SCOUT!!
48222f352f22bfb8.jpg

>
48222f713103cc78.jpg

>
48222f83317b46aa.jpg



Had to show me up again didn't you!!
 
Both Nice Bucks. I belivee that it is what you put into the the hunt that makes it your trouphy Buck. I belive that a respectable Buck today is something with Mass and 26" or wider. I have seen some nice Bucks that have been extremly tall and not very wide with deep forks and some trash. So i guess each of us have to decide before we pull the triger. What we are looking for in a trouphy Buck.




YOU CANT SHOOT THE BIG ONE, IF YOU GO AROUND SHOOTING ALL THE LITTLE ONES. ( Let them go, let them grow!!!!)


Later
 
LAST EDITED ON May-10-08 AT 11:03AM (MST)[p]These are the lead paragraphs of an article I wrote a while back titled, "IS IT A TROPHY?" -TONY

Competing for some warmth, two other guides and our six hunters from New Jersey and Texas huddled closer to the dwindling campfire. While they continued swapping hunting tales on that eve of the 1976 Colorado deer season opener, I placed a fresh log on the coals, then watched the flames prey on the hunk of wood.

The pine pitch warmed quickly. With no breeze to alter their route, the sooty smoke curls lingered a bit before drifting away into the night sky. I peered up at the star-flecked blackness and smiled, recalling a question my now 45-year-old son, Keith, had asked as an inquisitive 5-yr.old in 1967.

We had camped among the ponderosa pines in northeast Arizona?s White Mountains, and the mid-summer night temperature had fallen to the low 40s. Wrapped tightly in his heavy coat, Keith had pushed in tight against my wife for extra warmth and had intently focused on the fire. After 15 silent minutes, he suddenly asked, "Daddy, where does the smoke go."

Knowing I would have no plausible answer, my wife smiled when I told the toddler the smoke just goes all the way up to heaven.

Right then, a client interrupted my musing, but I heard only my name. "Sorry, I was dreaming. What did you say?"

The man from New Jersey repeated his question. "What do you think our chances of taking a good trophy are?"

Thinking about the irony, I paused several seconds. Although the question was less far-fetched than Keith?s had been, I had no definitive answer simply because I needed to know what comprised a trophy for him.

Little has changed since that night in 1976. Today, the adage, "Beauty is in the eyes of the beholder," still fits. The problem is one of definition; a trophy for one guy might be a non-shooter to the next guy.

At one time or another, many hunters will harbor the spirits and desires of a trophy hunter. Unfortunately, reality usually takes precedence over spirits and desires.....
 
Well, they certainly are all amazing Bucks! Now, we all know that there is a difference between public land, and a limited entry unit that is public land. I think the original poster was asking specifically about Utah's general season public land hunts.
 
The last respectable buck I saw was the one my took in the early 70's. I can't remember the year but back then the sporting goods stores had big buck contests. My dad won a boat motor and trailer from wolfs sporting goods. I will have to get the picks from my mother and post em. My dad has long past on so I should post the deer he took in him memory. I think ya'all will be impressed.
 
Any buck that has quit nursing is a good one. By the year 2020 a fawn buck in his mothers womb will be considered a keeper.



Ransom
 
Ransom, you gotta admit that if a good taxi job can capture the milk mustache, there is some coveted trophy factor in the boys that are still nursing.
 
anything over 18" on a general season tag is doin pretty good in this state right now.from what i've seen the further south you go the higher your expectations could get. ELK- those are some dandy bucks there.hard to believe those all came from general season public land this day and age,but i believe you.thanx 4 sharing!
 

Click-a-Pic ... Details & Bigger Photos
Back
Top Bottom