What does he score?

booner76 · Aug 11, 2011

You guy's have way more experience than I do scoring and judging muley's, would appreciate it if you guy's could give me your opinion's as to what this buck scores
here is the link, you will know which one, warning you it is a bad photo.
Thanks, booner
http://www.rustlersparadise.com/Recreation.html

liecabucks · Aug 11, 2011

If its the one on the Main page then he's about 180-185

Sit tall in the saddle, hold your head up high, keep your eyes fixed to where the trail meets the sky...

HiMtnHntr · Aug 11, 2011

25" wide, solid 185" gross.

MuleyMinor · Aug 11, 2011

155-160 Is my guess!!

ArcheryAddict · Aug 11, 2011

LAST EDITED ON Aug-11-11 AT 01:34PM (MST)[p]Looks quite similar to my buck I shot on opening day in the Nevada forum, so I am going to have to say 183" gross.

monstermuleyman · Aug 11, 2011

Its always a challenge to guess their "final" score when they are in velvet, but I would guess 26" wide and score right around 180".

powellpounder · Aug 11, 2011

165-170

eldorado · Aug 11, 2011

The rack is not wide but does have good mass and forks. I'd say 184.
Still a very good buck.

Eldorado

BuckSnort · Aug 11, 2011

Since it's here on MM I say 205"... Anywhere else.. 170"

Disclaimer:
The poster does not take any responsibility for any hurt or bad feelings. Reading threads poses inherent risks. The poster would like to remind readers to make sure they have a functional sense of humor before they visit any discussion board.

overton · Aug 11, 2011

>
>Since it's here on MM I
>say 205"... Anywhere else.. 170"
>
>
>

>
>Disclaimer:
>The poster does not take any
>responsibility for any hurt or
>bad feelings. Reading threads poses
>inherent risks. The poster would
>like to remind readers to
>make sure they have a
>functional sense of humor before
>they visit any discussion board.
>

Maybe even 210.

MichaelJ · Aug 11, 2011

175-180"... Great forks, solid main beams, good mass, great everything that counts in score except for width. Solid buck!

Mike
"What I could do, I was doing, and that was simply putting my butt on the line for my country, the country that I loved, so that all the protestors and the academics and the liberal intelligentsia back home could enjoy the right to protest against people like me, the hated middleclass." --Gary R. Smith, US Special Forces

bonepicker · Aug 11, 2011

No way does he go 180" and probably not even 170". His spread barely is wider than his ears. He has good deep forks so maybe 165" but we're looking at a velvet antlered buck and I'm not blown away by his mass so that means he probably doesn't have much mass when that velvet comes off. Weak eyguards too and it looks like he's about done growing so you're only going to get 2" maybe out of those. On their own the narrow spread, weak mass short eye guards wouldn't take too much off the final score but all of them together would probably drop it into the 160's. You've got to have it all to get into the 180's-190's. Still a nice buck though.

HalfAce · Aug 11, 2011

Hes got great symmetry, But ide put him in the low 170's. Pretty rack though.

TOPGUN · Aug 11, 2011

I have to agree with bonepicker. That buck is nice, but I doubt that he will make 170" when the velvet comes off.

slm2303 · Aug 11, 2011

one_dryboot · Aug 11, 2011

160's type buck + or - 10 for being a photo

sageadvice · Aug 11, 2011

I'd put him low 170's. Inside sp and mainbeams are holding him back. I'd be happy with that buck this year!!

Joey

Gator · Aug 11, 2011

178 could finish right on 180, 26" wide good mass, But not outstanding, Here in Ca (the only tag I drew) He would be a keeper 10 times over.Hell I would shoot him in all 11 western states.

"I have found if you go the extra mile it's Never crowded".

big6 · Aug 12, 2011

big6 · Aug 12, 2011

G1 1in g2 13 g3 10 g4 12 mb24 mass 16 eq. 76 76x2eq. 152+22inside 174 plus or minus some good deer for around my area dont know where this is at

huntindad4 · Aug 12, 2011

24 wide and might go 170.

Bill

Look out Forkie, FTW is watching us!

booner76 · Aug 12, 2011

Public Land Unit 2 Colorado.
I have a tag there this year, and am learning I am TERRIBLE at judging these muley's lol

wooly · Aug 12, 2011

I think he will be in the mid 170's

cabinfever · Aug 12, 2011

put me down for 180-185.pretty buck!!!!

liecabucks · Aug 12, 2011

uhm that there is one stud buck....I think you guys going with the 160's are definately smoking bad weed. He has awesome fronts, great backs and isnt spindly by any means. Put him on the ground and i'll buy you a steak dinner if he doesn't hit 180.

Sit tall in the saddle, hold your head up high, keep your eyes fixed to where the trail meets the sky...

Zeke · Aug 12, 2011

Great lookin' buck.
My opinion is he'll crack 170" really easily (prob mid to high 170's). He's a taker in almost every unit.

Zeke

one_dryboot · Aug 12, 2011

LAST EDITED ON Aug-12-11 AT 05:14PM (MST)[p]Ok after looking at him on my phone I thought high 160's. now looking on the puter I will say he is probably high 170's. He might break 180 but I wouldn't bet the farm on it!

BuckSnort · Aug 12, 2011

Any pics of his tracks we can look at?

Disclaimer:
The poster does not take any responsibility for any hurt or bad feelings. Reading threads poses inherent risks. The poster would like to remind readers to make sure they have a functional sense of humor before they visit any discussion board.