which deer is bigger mine or my fiance??

BF10

Member
Messages
5
My fiance shot the deer on the left last year during the rifle season and I shot the one on the right this year during the bow season. We just wanted to see which one you guys think is bigger.
56086745e111-dc07-4081-afcd-a496ac87227a.jpg
 
Both are nice bucks. Her buck looks to have better G4's and could make the difference if your scoring.

Eldorado
 
Your fiancee's buck was probably slightly bigger...just looking at the head; appears to be a slightly older buck as well. Both respectable bucks...one of those arguments you can have around all your future campfires at hunting camp...and which never will be quite satisfactorily settled! :)
 
Sweetheart!, I'll buy you a new Vette if you drop this small buck shooting bum and come live with me! :) j/k

Joey


"It's all about knowing what your firearms practical limitations are and combining that with your own personal limitations!"
 
BF10, Mine wasn't probably the usual comment that you were expecting from this awesome website Monstermuleys but i assure you that,.. it can get worse.lol

Welcome, nice bucks both but Sweetheart's there has the look!

Joey


"It's all about knowing what your firearms practical limitations are and combining that with your own personal limitations!"
 
>got any other pics......of your fiancee???
>
>
>
8346emporor_obama.jpg

>I liked it big...fondler doesn't

+1


"Go hunt for meat at Walmart."
 
>got any other pics......of your fiancee???
>
>
>
8346emporor_obama.jpg

>I liked it big...fondler doesn't


Yeah I have a more of her and her buck
 
She Definately has bigger fronts. Her backs are weak. I'd say she has a much bigger rack. I must be looking at something completely different than those two deer. Nice bucks and congrats.
 
I think they'll score out real close to each other. Her buck appears older with a little more mass. Both bucks are nice.
Congrats

And congrats on bagging the trophy fiance!! :)
 
BOTH NICE BUCKS, BUT YOUR BUCK IS A BOW KILL !!! HOWEVER..... SHE IS A LOT CUTER THAN YOU WILL EVER BE. HER BUCK WINS BY A LANDSLIDE...........................YD.
 
You must be the best salesman in the world!
She's pretty and you leave a lot to be desired!
LMAO.
(I had to see if my comment was as clever as Uncle Sage's)

Thy're both damn fine bucks. Always good to see the women-folk out in the field mixin' things up.

Congrats (on many levels) ha
Zeke
 
Nice bucks and congrats on the engagement/wedding...with regards to which one is bigger. I think they would gross almost exactly the same, within a few points of eachothers. Have you scored them?
 
On the fly her's looks bigger. After looking closer it is hard to tell.

If it's a tie, she gets extra credit for shooting it close to the road.
 
1690brendan_and_my_deer.jpg

I'm the fianc?...
These are two different pictures of our deer. He did shoot his with a bow but what he didn't mention was that I shot mine at over 300 yards during the rifle season last year. :)
 
Both look like 3 1/2 year old deer. Close to the same size. Hers shot earlier in the year his later. Nice job and congrats to both. If i was him id say her buck is the biggest.
 
His will score better because of deeper forks, but if they were standing side by side, I think I would shoot hers. Just a more mature looking deer with more mass.

That said, just keep saying her bucks are bigger, but if she ever asks you if something else of hers is bigger, the answer is always NO.

Great buck arae13 and welcome to monstermuleys! With a 300 yard shot and a bow shot, it would also be hard to say who had the most difficult! Congrats to you both!

txhunter58

venor, ergo sum (I hunt, therefore I am)
 
Your scores better. Her looks better. I think in the long run she will out do ya.

"I have found if you go the extra mile it's Never crowded".
>[Font][Font color = "green"]Life member of
>the MM green signature club.[font/]
 
I like your fianc?'s buck....plus she is prettier than you :)
Both really nice bucks...contrats to you both. Thanks for sharing the pics.

))))------->
 

Click-a-Pic ... Details & Bigger Photos
Back
Top Bottom