Since 2000 PA has more elk in B&C then Idaho, when you figure Idaho issues around 30,000 bull tags and PA 10 or so PA is unreal, so bottom line is that seems reasonable.
Wish they had a different point system so I might draw in my lifetime. Now they cap at 3, 98% of guys have 3 points, thus points do not help at all.
That elk is legit. I saw that picture on the PA hunting message board. I could not locate the picture of the bull down, but I believe in the 1st link the 2nd picture is the same bull on the hoof. The 2nd link is a couple nice bulls as well. As far as the B&C score I don't know, I am not that good at scoring bulls yet. I will say that PA has some nice elk, albeit very few of them.