Do not quote me but I think most states only allow xbows for elk during rifle seasons, except WY where you can hunt bow. I could be wrong. A crossbow is way more then powerfull enough and accurate enough for elk, as said above they are unfair vs handheld bows, huge difference IMO. Here in Ohio xbows and legal for all of bow season. I too have heard guys say 100 yards is doable (not that I agree - but the point is accuracy and energy wise they are unreal). I do think guys who have health issues should be allowed to use them. Youth I can see too, I wonder if most kids can shoot a powerful enough bow to get the job done - interesting idea. I normally not a xbow fan but in this situation it might not be a bad idea.