Why?? Spidey Goin Out Of State...

Clyde Hollinger

Active Member
Messages
776
Well, I gotta hand it to the Mossback crew for stickin it out.. Even though I'm not happy abput it.. Gotta give credit where credit is due. Sure would be nice to be able to dedicate all that time to one bull with 500 guys looking for you... The thing that REALLY bugs me is that Spidey and several of the past records that have came out of Utah have gone to out of staters... This bug anyone else??

Elk
 
LAST EDITED ON Sep-30-08 AT 04:59PM (MST)[p]LAST EDITED ON Sep-30-08 AT 04:05?PM (MST)

The non-typ record that was taken in 2002 was by Jeff Diedrickson (Utah Res.). It was just beat last year by Jimmy Ryan's (non res.) archery monster. 2003 Brian Gilson's (Utah Res.) ,first 400 typ., beat the 1999 record of Phillip Tuttle (Utah res.) The typical record was then broke in 2005 by Lloyd Jacobsons (Utah res.) 415 net monster. Then in 2006 Ron Skoronski's(non res.) 426 net took over the crown. None of these bulls were taken with the Goveners tag and one was with the sportsmans tag (utah res.). I believe Spider is the first Goveners tag bull to be a state record. So in the last two years typ. and one year non-typ. state records have been held by non residents. I guess I'm saying it doesn't bug me.
 
I pretty much figured it wouldn't bug you Peak... We all kinda know where you stand anyway... But, that's ok, to each his own I guess...

Elk
 
Elkster, in response to your rhetorical question at the end of your post "This bug anyone else?" No, it doesn't bug me, not at all. What does bug me is the amount of trash that I saw while walking around the Monroe unit. I've never been anywhere on a National Forest where I've seen more beer cans strewn about on the ATV trails. More than once, I wandered along wondering how a state with so many residents who are LDS can have so many beer cans laying around the forest. Is the remainder of the population that big a bunch of slobs, or are there just way more jack mormons than I would have expected?

I was alos bugged by the number of slob hunters I saw who rode around in the back of a pickup with bows, arrows nocked and ready to shoot at the first legal buck they saw. I've never hunted anywhere that I saw as much of this behavior as I did on Monroe. Toward the end of our hunt, we even ran into a group on a big Ford diesel that were riding on a 'hitch haul' platform on the back of the truck, with their bows laying across a padded dog box in the back, arrows nocked and ready to go go battle. I wondered how those nice folks we passed who were out riding ATVs regarded those slob hunters when they passed each other, right after we passed both groups.

That stuff bugged me, but a non-resident killing this bull doesn't bother me at all. Does the non-resident money he paid to Utah for his governor's tag also bother you? After all, that money was residing in Idaho until he came to Utah and contributed significantly to the local economy to go elk hunting for nearly a month.
 
Sorry Elkster...you made me think about it a little. I think it's awesome how many records have been from draw tags vs. Gov. tags.
 
Being from Canada, Im not very familiar on how alot of the tags and draws work in the US. I was hoping someone could fill me in on this Gov tag. Thanks


early to bed, early to rise, hunt like hell and make up lies!
 
CAelknuts,

All those beer cans must be from out of staters..LOL..and did you catch the state plate on the Ford? I'm sure it was from out of state too...LOL...did you get any pics of that truck/trailer combo. I bet Jeff Foxworthy would buy it from you.
 
I'm with Elknuts on this one. I don't care where they came from, as long they hunt ethically and responsibly. I think it's great that out of state guys will bring that kind of money into your economy.
 
I think it's kind of funny that the bull lasted for SO long with SO MANY freakin' people chasing him.

Nobody gave this bull a chance to live out the first week with all the legends chasing him, and he lasted way longer than anyone expected.

That kind of makes me smile and chuckle a little. I guess sometimes we aren't as good as we think we are. ;-)

But I don't care who killed it. Money generally wins out, in hunting and every other aspect of life. Just the way it is.

But it's a pretty impressive bull no matter what. I'm sure another one will come along eventually and make everyone forget this one.

Congrats to whoever killed it. It's about damn time. LOL!!
 
LAST EDITED ON Sep-30-08 AT 04:36PM (MST)[p]Peak,

Great response man. Well thought out and spot on.

Ca, I couldn't aggree with you more.

buck1.gif


Later, Brandon
 
I think if any Utah residents are upset that a non-resident comes in and harvests any world record animal, that anger is just a form a jealousy in my eyes. Obviously any of us would LOVE to be the guy or gal to get that bull but to be upset about it is rediculous. Res or non-res taking him should matter none...also like the comment on how it helps our economy...because God and everyone else knows how jacked up that thing is right now haha!!

~Z~
 
Cali,
Kinda sounds like the experience I have every time I visit California: Gutters full of trash, reckless drivers every 100 yards of driving, smog filling the sky, and filthy beaches. I combat this by not going any more.

I hunt several states, and the mountains in Utah seem to be the most friendly, clean, and overall the best place to go.

You can certainly do what I have done and choose a different state to visit.

For the record I really could care less who killed the bull and where they are from. I treat resident and non resident hunters the same.
 
+1 bowhunt. I'm just glad he's dead and we, "the local trash" can have our mountain back for a while. It is a beautiful place.

"We can have no "50-50" allegiance in this country. Either a man is an American and nothing else, or he is not an American at all".
Theodore Roosevelt
 
LAST EDITED ON Sep-30-08 AT 05:11PM (MST)[p]LAST EDITED ON Sep-30-08 AT 05:09?PM (MST)

Peak... Yeah, I've always thought you were an upstanding guy, and you know your stuff. Thanks for the insight.
CA... I agree Utah has some retards when it comes to road hunting, no doubt about it. The big money does bug me a little, yeah... But, whatever.... It's not worth arguing about. I enjoyed reading about your experience on the Monroe. Glad you had a good time. That being said, if it was such a dirty place with so many slobs running around... Maybe you'll have second thoughts about coming to Utah to hunt our elk herds again... Just a thought...???
Brow... You're awesome man! I'm honored to brothers in arms with you!

Later!
 
>Elkster, in response to your rhetorical
>question at the end of
>your post "This bug anyone
>else?" No, it doesn't
>bug me, not at all.
> What does bug me
>is the amount of trash
>that I saw while walking
>around the Monroe unit.
>I've never been anywhere on
>a National Forest where I've
>seen more beer cans strewn
>about on the ATV trails.
> More than once, I
>wandered along wondering how a
>state with so many residents
>who are LDS can have
>so many beer cans laying
>around the forest.


WWWWAHHHAHHHHHHAAAAHAHAHAHAHHA

I think I just found a new best friend. I knew I like you elknut
 
"More than once, I wandered along wondering how a state with so many residents who are LDS can have so many beer cans laying around the forest. Is the remainder of the population that big a bunch of slobs, or are there just way more jack mormons than I would have expected?"

Why would you bring religion into this?

I could care less if an out of stater killed it; dead is dead.
 
eastkoothunter,
it is a program that all the western states have. It is one tag for a specific species that gets auctioned off to the highest bidder. depending on the state and species it can go for as much as $150k. Each state varies on the length of season and what/when different types of weapons can be used.
Like arizona is good for nearly 365 days, other states are from the 1st season to the end of the last season or longer.
As far as the weapons go some are any weapon throughout the season others are you have to use the weapon of the current season.
Very short summary but hope that helps you.

Mntman

"Hunting is where you prove yourself"
 
LAST EDITED ON Sep-30-08 AT 06:06PM (MST)[p]LAST EDITED ON Sep-30-08 AT 06:05?PM (MST)

"More than once, I wandered along wondering how a
state with so many residents who are LDS can have
so many beer cans laying around the forest."

LOL LOL LOL LOL LOL.......WOW! LDS people up there throwing beer cans offside the road........Good observation.... I really enjoyed following your elk hunt step by step in your previous post, but the Beer Cans and LDS?????? Wow, ya lost a fan.....No need for that.....
 
LAST EDITED ON Sep-30-08 AT 06:53PM (MST)[p]I wonder how many people would even know about spidey if it were not for mossback. In fact, I am pretty sure the pic that floats around this website of spidey was taken from a team mossback video trailer.

As for out of state hunters - wow - really does it matter to you who kills the 500 inch bull if it aint you??? Gettin pretty touchy if you do.
 
No kidding! What does religion have to do with this?

I am LDS and I love beer!;-)

I agree with the guy who said dead is dead. Who cares who shot it? It was not me and it will not change how I put on my britches tommorow.
 
Congrats to the Utah boys that put the shooter on the bull Congrats to the State for producing such a fine bull
Congrats to the hunter that tagged it and thank you for the funds.

The only non-res issue I have is the slam on us non-LDS beer drinkers.
 
Who gives a crap what state he is from? Last time I checked we are all Americans around here. Its not like a freakin' Frenchman shot him.
 
Hey, I just got back from having some beers with Bishop Austad. That freakin Frenchman can drink you under the table. What's been happening on MM?
 
I'm glad to see that I got some people's panties all wadded up. Perhaps I wasn't as articulate as I should have been, so let me elaborate. First, I have quite a few neighbors who live around me here in California who are LDS, and some of them are great friends; so don't get the idea that I have any beef with that aspect at all, because I surely don't. I have a lot of respect for their morals, certainly more than some other demographic groups.

What I was perplexed about is that since Utah has a high LDS population, there is a large percentage of the populace who doesn't drink alcohol, or very little alcohol; therefore it was surprising to see so many beer cans strewn along trails. I am sure that I saw at least 35-40 beer cans dumped here and there. It has nothing to do with anyone who's mormon, but when you consider that most mormons wouldn't be drinking, you eliminate a large portion of the population who might have dumped a beer can in the woods. That gave me the impression that a small portion of the outdoor using public are a bunch of slobs. I'm being serious when I say I haven't seen that much trash in the woods in a long time; I haven't! Whether you agree or not, I thought that it sucked to hike all the way to the crest of the range to the west of Barney Lake, to come out at 10,700+ feet, and find beer cans laying along the trail. Sheesh, if someone needed a beer that bad that they would pack it all the way up there, then why can't they pack it back with them when they've emptied the can? They're uncaring slobs, that's why. If my comments are construed as pointing a finger at someone on here, so be it. Think next time before you dump trash in the forest. The rest of us, regarless of our beliefs, will appreciate it.

As for the comments about people road hunting from vehicles with arrows nocked on bows, is there really a need to do that? I mean, seriously, if you are so lazy and such a poor hunter that you have to ride around hoping to get a shot at a deer WITH A BOW from your pickup, do you really need to be out in the woods? I could actually almost understand it if they were rifle hunting, at least they'd be able to shoot a deer from the vehicle (even though it's illegal in most or all states to shoot from a vehicle on a public road), but with a bow you're not going to get any kind of quality shot, and I have no doubt that an unacceptable portion of the deer shot by these SHOOTERS are wounded and lost. The people who engage in this sorry behavior give all hunters a black eye, especially on a unit such as Monroe where the hunters are sharing the woods with so many non-hunting people who are simply out there enjoying the forest. If you think the non-hunting public has an impression of hunters besides those slobs they ran into on the roads with bows in their hands while in a vehicle, I'd love to know what it is. They sure as heck never ran into me out in the woods on foot, because they don't go in those spots. I actually ran across a pickup with a long bed, that had bench seats set in the middle, with three shooters facing out to both sides, six shooters total, and they all had arrows nocked on their bows. I wonder what happened if they ever ran into a poor yearling buck? Talk about blazing saddles... Good thing Custer wasn't around, he'd have thought it was deja vu all over again!

Again, religion had nothing to do with my comments other than to illustrate how a relatively small portion of those out in the woods, the largely non-LDS portion, can have such a large negative impact. If more people ascribed to some of the values that my LDS friends believe in, a lot of places, perhaps especially California, would be better off. This place is more screwed up than most anywhere else, and I look forward to the day I retire and move out of this screwed up state. I promise I won't bring Nancy Pelosi or Maxine Waters with me.
 
That helps alot, thank you. I enjoy reading all these posts and felt outta the loop, but that helps me understand whas going on and stuff.


early to bed, early to rise, hunt like hell and make up lies!
 
Wow CAelknuts, That was a low blow. Bringing religion into it? Following your novel on here it sounded like you had a great experience here in Utah and then you post that?
 
I get really effin tired of guys rippin on California hunters.
WTF?
On my last muley trip to Oregon the worst offenders were the locals and some dude with...yes...ALASKA plates on his pickup with his rifle barrel pointing out the window road hunting.

Generally out of staters have way more invested in the hunt and treat it more respectfully.

JMO.

HH
 
Who is Rippin on CA hunters? Better check with CAELKNUTS.....his stay was pretty comfortable here in Utah.
 
Again, elkoholic, read my last post. I WAS NOT bagging on any religion. Rather, I was commenting about how a small percentage of the population that isn't part of that religion can have such an outsized impact on the forest. With such a large portion of the population NOT being disposed toward carrying beer cans around in their hands, I was surprised at how many beer cans we found laying around trails in the woods.

You guys that only read 1/2 of the story need to follow Paul Harvey's tagline that says "And now you know the rest of the story."
 
>Who is Rippin on CA hunters?
> Better check with CAELKNUTS.....his
>stay was pretty comfortable here
>in Utah.


Not in this thread, but I've been here a long time and have seen countless refrences over the years.
Ask around.

HH
 
LAST EDITED ON Sep-30-08 AT 10:51PM (MST)[p]And by the way, elkoholic, yes I had a fantastic time. Were it not for elkster's comments and question that started this thread, I never would have commented on how running into beer cans in the woods and slob hunters on the roads bothered me. The guy asked if a non-resident killing that bull bothered anyone, and I responded to his question, while also elaborating and expanding to talk about something that did bother me. It does bother me that there are people who have a need to feel ill will toward non-residents, in part because we're all non-residents of every state but one. I don't have any ill will toward those of any faith, or Utahans or any group, other than slobs. A slob is a slob no matter where he's from or what he believes. That's not a low blow at all, unless you happen to be one of the slobs that feels my comments were directed a little too close to home.

Some of the finest and most generous people I've ever met while hunting were people I met on this hunt. I now count them as valued friends and hope to share some good times with them in the future. I know that they aren't slobs. I don't know about the other aspects of their lives. It doesn't matter to me, I like and respect them for who they are, just the way they are.

Californians take more than our share of criticism about lots of stuff, and some of it is well deserved but a lot isn't. In some ways, that's similar to the way the Governors tag holder is perceived. Some guys don't like or respect him just because he was able to do something most of us never will be able to do. On the other hand, I guess some of you guys don't appreciate finding out how people perceive the slobs that are out there. People who tolerate that kind of behavior are more of the problem than anyone who points it out. And that is regardless of where they're from or what they believe. If more people didn't tolerate that kind of behavior and lack of ethics, we'd all be better off.
 
Couple of weeks back we was headed up to Wyo for a little stroll in the backcountry and as we was hauling butt down the 15, I'm looking out and I see what I thought at first was some elk moving out some trees but it turned out to be some kids riding horses and they looked like they was driving the trees for deer I think, But what was funny was one of the bowhunters was riding double with his bow in hand with a arrow nocked,I wouldn't call that road hunting but it looked like they was doing a drive-by in the hood on some deer. I wonder if they got one.
 
Just be glad that he didn't end up in Idaho and where government assassins would have run him to death and probably not even taken a bite.
 
Nice clarification elknuts and thanks for explaining your thoughts. It really pi__es me off to know there are people out there leaving trash like that and I would agree with you in calling them "slobs".
I do want to help you understand why there are so many beer cans in our mountains coming from a state that is predominate LDS. The mountains are the only place we can go to drink our beer where our Bishops won't see us!
J/K, it's just all those damn Richfield folks I guess...
 
LAST EDITED ON Oct-01-08 AT 08:27AM (MST)[p]LAST EDITED ON Oct-01-08 AT 08:26?AM (MST)

LAST EDITED ON Oct-01-08 AT 08:25?AM (MST)

"I was alos bugged by the number of slob hunters I saw who rode around in the back of a pickup with bows, arrows nocked and ready to shoot at the first legal buck they saw. I've never hunted anywhere that I saw as much of this behavior as I did on Monroe. Toward the end of our hunt, we even ran into a group on a big Ford diesel that were riding on a 'hitch haul' platform on the back of the truck, with their bows laying across a padded dog box in the back, arrows nocked and ready to go go battle. I wondered how those nice folks we passed who were out riding ATVs regarded those slob hunters when they passed each other, right after we passed both groups." - CAelknuts



That cracks me up and I keep getting a mental picture of the scene from the original "JAWS" movie where all the local fisherman are riding around in the bay, running over each other, shooting guns in the water, drinking beer by the tub, all to slay JAWS, a.k.a. Spidey. I bet the scene on the mountain was very similar.


T264
 
Congrats to Denny. Makes no difference to me where that bull ends up. I would love to see Denny's trophy room with all those big Utah bulls. After reading the post this morning I can only think of two animals in my house from my home state the other few dozen from the rest of the West and Canada.
 
Caelknuts,

I guess Im the only LDS guy on here who actually got what you meant in your first post. I guess some people need a few courses on reading comprehnsion, since it was OBVIOUS that he was not taking a shot at anyones religion.

Seriously people, get your panties out of a wad, take the team to read what was written, ponder what the meaning was, and THEN and only then should you post a reply.

Oh, and to the OP,

I dont care who killed it, as long as it was done legally, all I can say is congrats to the hunter.
 
CAelknut,
I got what you meant with your first post and have to say that I agree with you.

It has nothing to do with religion, it was an observation and thank you for posting it.

I also think the guys posting that maybe people shouldn't come there to hunt are self serving individuals who are more than likely the ones dumping trash up there. Hoping it ruins the hunting experience enough that NR's won't come back. Who knows?

I would rather have a DIY hunter tag the record bull , no matter what state he was from, than have it go to a guided hunter.
 
LAST EDITED ON Oct-01-08 AT 10:03AM (MST)[p]Quote from CAelknuts:
"That gave me the impression that a small portion of the outdoor using public are a bunch of slobs. I'm being serious when I say I haven't seen that much trash in the woods in a long time; I haven't! Whether you agree or not, I thought that it sucked to hike all the way to the crest of the range to the west of Barney Lake, to come out at 10,700+ feet, and find beer cans laying along the trail. Sheesh, if someone needed a beer that bad that they would pack it all the way up there, then why can't they pack it back with them when they've emptied the can? They're uncaring slobs, that's why. If my comments are construed as pointing a finger at someone on here, so be it. Think next time before you dump trash in the forest. The rest of us, regarless of our beliefs, will appreciate it."

I agree with this and it makes me sick! I am from Utah and it is getting harder and harder all the time just finding a place to go shooting. I live in Utah county and have been shooting west of Utah lake for years. But more and more, there is trash everywhere. People bring all types of trash (furniture, computer monitors, TVs, etc), shoot it all up and just leave it! It looks like a big garbage dump and places are starting to be shut down. It drives me crazy! Don't people have more respect for themselves and their environment than that?

When I go shooting, I always take my kids and several garbage bags. We go around picking up all the garbage left by others including hundreds and even thousands of shotgun shells. We don't even go to the more popular places any more for fear of being hit by a stray bullet.

Just three weeks ago, we were shooting against the mountain side. We were backed about 300 yards away from the mountain because we were shooting at targets 300 yards away. Along comes this red truck, drives right by us and parks in between us and our targets. I was sure that they simply had made a mistake so we went up there and talked to them. Their response was, "Well, you had better find a new place to shoot then hadn't you!" I couldn't believe it. I wanted to shoot them right there. We had a few words but I decided to keep a cool head. I packed everything and the kids up and we drove farther up the road into a more desolate part of the desert.

So yes CAelknuts, I agree with you. There are a lot of slobs out here. Both in the trash that they leave and the trash that they are. And it is slowly ruining it for the rest of us.

Sorry for the ranting but it really is starting to bug me too!
 
Ok, aside from the JACK MO'S issue at hand, did I read correctly that this guy that shot Spidey is from IDAHO? Just need a clarification. If thats the case, so what if the Bull is going to the neighboring state of IDAHO. God knows Utah is always up in Idaho, so I guess this can be payment for all the speeding and reckless driving they do in Idaho. (Giggle.)
 
I don't post alot,but felt compelled to at least throw my two cents worth in. I spend a great deal of time on the Monroe. My family has a cabin on top. I love that mountain. One thing I have noticed is that with the numerous piute trails that are well known and mapped out for all to enjoy, we are getting all kinds of people from every state on that mountain. there was even a jamboree of some type while the hunt was going on. My point is that the mountain has gotten trashier ( if thats a word) the more atv traffic coming from not just Utahns, but from people ( slobs ) from all walks of life. I hate to see it and take every opportunity to teach my boys to pick up any trash they see while we are out hiking.
Anyway, on a better note I would of welcomed CAelknuts to our cabin to stay but we had a hunter in our camp. We stayed away from the spidey circus and he ended up getting a nice 340 bull.
 
Tuff wrote,
"I guess Im the only LDS guy on here who actually got what you meant in your first post. I guess some people need a few courses on reading comprehnsion, since it was OBVIOUS that he was not taking a shot at anyones religion."

Tuff maybe you could be the teacher.:)
 
What really bugg's me, what really get's under my skin, what really chaps my hide is that the wrong non-resident shot spidey.If only I'd had a tag it would have been me.
 
>Tuff wrote,
>"I guess Im the only LDS
>guy on here who actually
>got what you meant in
>your first post. I guess
>some people need a few
>courses on reading comprehnsion, since
>it was OBVIOUS that he
>was not taking a shot
>at anyones religion."
>
>Tuff maybe you could be the
>teacher.:)

Not until they improve teachers wages!! :)
 
After being a member of MM for 4 years I am about to make my 200th post, WOW, what a milestone.

CA, I wasn't offended by your comments at all and I didn't take it as a slam on my religion. You were just wondering why there are so many beer cans in areas where the predominant relgion doesn't drink beer (at least most of them don't). Like others have said, a slob is a slob no matter where he is from or what his religion. And like most of you, I am also sickened by those that leave trash for others to clean up. The one problem that I do see is that on MM we can't reach every single hunter and tell them to clean up their garbage. I assume most guys on this site are very serious when it comes to hunting and also preserving what we have for future generations. But, there are a lot of guys out there that aren't a part of MM and our message doesn't reach them.

I know that most of you guys and gals have and will teach your children that our mountains should be preserved and kept as clean and pristine as possible. I commend you for that. Hopefully one day these "slobs" will see the light and start to care about something besides themselves.
 
LITTERING IS A MUCH BIGGER FINE THAN AN OPEN CONTAINER IN UTAH, SO WHY DON'T YOU BEER CAN LITTERING SLOBS JUST CHUCK 'EM IN THE BACK OF THE TRUCK? PROBLEM SOLVED. BTW, I'M NOT INTERESTED IN THE TEACHERS POSITION EITHER UNTIL THEY RAISE THE PAY.
 
LAST EDITED ON Oct-01-08 AT 02:45PM (MST)[p]rutnelk

I'm looking forward to your daily elk hunt reports.
 
If the state of UT residents dont give a ##### that these tags can be sold to the highest bidders why would they give a ##### if the bidder was out of state??
 
I don't know about the bull. I think that Old Mossback raised that bull on a ranch and when he got the other rifle hunters out of the way he set it free. Im curious has anyone seen this bull before this year? My mom works for the fish and game, and every winter they fly that area. To my knowledge it was not seen last winter. A bull that big can't hide to good.
 
Another thing you moss-lovers might think about,..These last two bulls (spider and the 2007 443)were spending a ton their time on private land, so forget the idea that there were tons of guys out after spider, well after him yes, but able to go where he was, not exactly. The landowners were paid off last year to keep everone but mossy out and I am pretty sure it was the same here.






^BIGBONE^
 
LAST EDITED ON Oct-01-08 AT 10:11PM (MST)[p]Congratulations Bigbone! You're the winner of the 'I'm completely uninformed, but gonna comment anyway' award for tonight!

The Spider Bull did spend some of his time on private land this summer, but he never knew the difference. Almost all, or maybe even all, of that private land doesn't have any fences or nothing more than a 3-strand barbed wire fence surrounding it. Mostly, its just cabins on some acreage out in the forest. To say that anyone at all could control where the bull spent his time or who could access it demonstrates how completely uninformed you are. I only put over 500 miles on my truck in that unit last month, and can say that there are damned few fences anywhere, public or private, on the Monroe unit. Most of the fences I saw appeared to be related to grazing allotments or were old log fences constructed many years ago, presumably by the Forest Servie or Civilian Conservation Corps. The elk were jumping those fences like they were nothing at all.
 
I was told but don't know how true it is that the land owner was offered alot of money to let them hunt and he turned it down. That may be what made it hard for them to get it done sooner.
 

Click-a-Pic ... Details & Bigger Photos
Back
Top Bottom