My 2005 SE Idaho Muley

BrianID

Very Active Member
Messages
2,148
September 20th

My morning started out with elk feeding and bugling about 1/2 mile away. I once again started questioning my choice about buying a ?B tag? so I could hunt bulls later with my rifle. These elk continued to sing to me the rest of the day.

Before the sun started to rise above the crest of the mountain I watch a nice buck bed down. I wasn?t able to get a very good look at his antlers but he was large enough to get me interested. I was also watching three smaller bucks feed on an open hillside. None of these bucks were large enough to get me very interested but it was still enjoyable to watch them until they bedded down.

I decided to wait a couple hours before putting a stalk on the lone buck. I thought he might get up later in the morning and move because he had bedded down at first light. I also wanted to wait for the breeze to start blowing up hill. Sure enough he got out of his bed around 9:30am and feed for about a half an hour before bedding down again. A half hour latter I made my move and was 200 yards above the lone buck by 11 am. I couldn't spot any antler tips in the thick brush but was still confident he was still there. After trading my boots for a second pair of wool socks I was able to move within 50 yards of were I watched him disappear in a small thicket. I slowly moved in closer until I was less than 10 yards of where I thought he might be bedded. I knew he had to be there somewhere but still couldn't spot any gray hair or tip of an antler. Suddenly I heard a deer blow and saw him leap from his bed only 15 yards away. As I watched him bound away with his heavy antlers I was disappointed that I was so close without having a shot but also felt some accomplishment knowing that I had been within 30 yards of this wise old buck for the last half hour.

It was now almost 1pm and I started to head back to my truck. Instead of heading strait back I decided to take a detour and put a quick stalk on the three smaller bucks that I saw bed down earlier. I had no intention of shooting any of them but wanted to do a quick practice stalk. When I was about 70 yards from the bushy tree that I saw them bed under I was able to spot the top 4? of an antler from one of the bucks. I continued to slowly move closer until I was 30 yards from this deer. He was a decent sized three point and about 20? wide. I sat there for about 5 minutes and watched him chew his cud. Even though he had larger antlers than anything else that I had killed with my bow I still didn't want to put my tag on him.

26b3ee12.jpg

Here?s a picture of the bushy tree that the three were bedded under.

I wanted to see if I could get them to stand up so I took a small rock and threw it over the top of where the three were bedded.

-to be continued-
 
Cool story. It is always better with pictures. The suspense is building....
 
About 10 seconds after the rock landed I saw the largest of the three bucks walk out from under the tree. The temptation was starting to build. I took an arrow out of my quiver and knocked it. Before I drew back I question if I should hold out for one of the ?Whiteys?. Whitey Jr. and Whitey Sr. are a couple of muleys that I had seen a few time in early August but still couldn't find after over a dozen other mornings of glassing. At this point my wife was also getting sick at tired of mule deer and I thought it was better if I put the season to an end. I judged him to be 35 yards away but with the steep down hill angle I put my 30 yard pin right where I wanted to hit him behind the shoulder. As I was releasing the arrow I saw him take a step but it was too late the arrow was already on its way. I watched my arrow disappear in his chest about 8? farther back than I was aiming. He only took a couple quick steps and looked around for a short moment and then started to feed. Considering his strange reaction I was starting to question if I had hit him. Less than a minute after I shot I was able to see a red spot toward the back of the rib cage. He was only about 40 yards away and continued to feed with one of the smaller bucks next to him for the next five minutes. The smaller buck got in his way so he prodded the two point with his antlers.

I was starting to wonder if I had hit him in the liver instead of the lungs. He was now 50 yards away but I felt like I should put another arrow in him. I didn't account for the ark in my arrow and it was deflected by one of the only braches on the whole hillside. He ran about 75 yards off to my right and looked around for a minute but all three bucks still had no idea about what was going on.

It was now 2pm and 10 minutes after I shot him. I watched him bed down and less than a minute latter I could see his antlers fall to the side. I wasn?t positive that he was dead so I decided to wait an hour before I went to look for my arrow. I made a quick climb to the top of the hill so I could get cell coverage and let my wife know I would be home late.
a676fdbe.jpg

I quickly found my arrow. There was some foamy red blood but there was also some slightly darker blood on part of the arrow. A couple minutes latter I found my second arrow and as I suspected it was clean.
 
Hey Brian what are you trying to do...another "San Juan Thread"? Congrats on taking a buck, love the story so far, don't make us wait 30 days for the end!
 
LAST EDITED ON Sep-29-05 AT 04:57PM (MST)[p]I felt confident that he was dead so I went to the spot I saw his antlers fall to the side when he was bedded. After not finding him there I started to circle the area and look for blood. After almost 30 minutes of searching I found no blood and no deer. I was starting to worry that he may have gotten back up and I was in for a long night. I was still confident that I saw him fall over dead in his bed so I went back to the spot that I last saw him.
e394b96b.jpg

This is what I saw in the thick brush about 10 yards down hill of were I saw him bed down. I must have walked within 15 yards of him several times.

more pictures later
 
You can see the exit hole in picture below. My arrow hit one lung and cut part of the diaphragm but didn't hit the liver. He?s not all that big but I'm happy with him. He was only mile from the road but it was all up hill. Between the two trips it took me close to six hours of cutting and packing but it was worth it. It was also nice listen to the elk bugle as I was cutting him up. Anyway I'm going to go cook up some back straps.
cfaab6d4.jpg
 
Wonderful story! You are obviously a very skilled hunter! Congratulations on a fine animal.

Steve
 
idhunters,
I have dial up so it takes a little while to upload the pics and type the story so I thought I would just post it as I go. I'll post a couple more pics for those of you that would like to guess some of the measurements.
 
Here are some more pics for those of you that would like to guess the score.
Early next week I'll post the gross score and height.
I don't have any head on pictures of the antlers when they are still connected to the head so I'll give
everyone I hint by telling you that he is 21" wide.
I judged him to be 21? wide on the hoof but was about 8? low judging the gross score.
IMG019.jpg

IMG001.jpg

IMG007.jpg


The highlight of my hunting season is over.
I still have a ?X tags? for cow elk and whitetail doe.
A good friend and I have a ?B tags? for elk and will have fun camping and probably sore backs from packing one bull out if not two.
At the moment I'm still more excited about my 2006 muley tag than my bull elk hunt in a couple of weeks.
 
Congrats on the buck, and great story!

Kirby

When in doubt, floor it.

Diplomacy is the art of saying "nice doggy" until you find a big stick.
 
Brian,
Great story and better pictures! We're going to try and get some video of our late muzz hunt south of Burley in November. I can only hope to have the success you have already experienced. Both taking a nice buck with a primitive weapon and getting some great "in-field" pictures.

Congratulations!!! Hope you get a bull also!
 
Brian,
Great story and better pictures! We're going to try and get some video of our late muzz hunt south of Burley in November. I can only hope to have the success you have a
 
That's a nice buck, congrats on stickin' him, liked the way you did the story too.

Keep the Sun at Your Back and the Wind in Your Face
 

Click-a-Pic ... Details & Bigger Photos
Back
Top Bottom