NEW Guess The Score Contest!

Founder · Mar 1, 2007

OK, let's see who can get this one.
Submit guess here--->http://www.monstermuleys.com/guessscore/guess.html

Brian Latturner
MonsterMuleys.com

Lawrence · Mar 1, 2007

197 6/8.

idabigbuck · Mar 1, 2007

I'm going to enjoy my new hat and tee-shirt, and I have a great place picked for my sticker too!

WAsharpstick · Mar 1, 2007

larrbo · Mar 1, 2007

186 1/8

maddglasser · Mar 1, 2007

I'm going to say 185 and 3/8 but hard to tell what the spread is is.

huntscout · Mar 1, 2007

187 3/8

YukonDall · Mar 1, 2007

190 3/8

live2huntmuleys · Mar 1, 2007

184 1/8

Muleyslyr · Mar 1, 2007

196 4/8

ICMDEER · Mar 1, 2007

I'm thinking you guys are way too low. 203 and 6/8, and maybe more. Heckuva deer.

muleyman · Mar 1, 2007

192 1/8

muleyman

cabinfever · Mar 1, 2007

I'm pretty sure those aspen tounge and grove slats are 4 inches tall. If you use this as your measuring tool this buck is well over 200.

left
MB=27
G1=3.5
G2=19
G3=13.5
G4=12
mass=18
NT point=1

right
MB=27.5
G1=3.5
G2=19.5
G3=14
G4=13
mass=18
NT point 2.5
inside spread= 23

215 gross. this buck nets b&c all day long. if I take an inch of of every measurment except for the mass and the NT points this buck is still over 200. Can't wait to see the final score on this one.

Mike

browtine · Mar 1, 2007

Make sure you guys post your guesses in the contest... you wont get credit for them by posting in this thread.

Later, Brandon

slider · Mar 1, 2007

alwayzbhuntin · Mar 1, 2007

THERE'S NOWHERE TO POST IT ON THE CONTEST PAGE LIKE THE LAST ONE? UNLESS I MISSED IT???

browtine · Mar 1, 2007

Click Here to Enter Contest
http://www.monstermuleys.com/guessscore/guess.html

Later, Brandon

BBB · Mar 1, 2007

Thanks for the contest...We needed some fresh air in here.

JakeH · Mar 1, 2007

LAST EDITED ON Mar-02-07 AT 01:00AM (MST)[p]Cabinfever, you also have to concider that some of those tines are 2' from that wall makeing them look bigger than they really are. I would subtract atleast 2"s off of all your tines and give it 16"s of mass instead of 18. No way are those 27" mb as well. I would say the guess's between 184 and 195 are pretty close. That is a good Idea though you just need to adjust it a bit.

Jake H. MM Member since 1999.

wallhanger · Mar 2, 2007

Wow, I must have way underestimated this deer. I don't see the mass you guys are talking about. I guessed him 181-ish. Now I'm really interested to see.

WH

GHOSTINTHEWOODS · Mar 2, 2007

191 6/8

cabinfever · Mar 2, 2007

Jake, I thought about that after I posted it, but even at that this deer scores higher than guys are guessing. Maybe I'll be eating crow after the true score is revealed.

30buck · Mar 2, 2007

Man i guess i underestimated also I'm only getting around 177-182

jds · Mar 2, 2007

cabinfever · Mar 2, 2007

the g3's and one g4 on the right side appear to be all over 12 inches

T264 · Mar 2, 2007

LAST EDITED ON Mar-02-07 AT 01:48PM (MST)[p]I put in 196 2/8 gross a couple days ago. I think his mass is very average and that his tine length is fantastic all the way around along with 25" main beams. Good or should I say great deer.

T264

P.S. 7 1/2 to 8" of brow tines don't hurt his score either.

camuleycrazy · Mar 2, 2007

I guessed 192 and something yesterday.

ForkWest · Mar 2, 2007

189 5/8

zekers · Mar 2, 2007

cabinfever, I think you are close on measurements except for the main beams. I think he is definately high 190's. Can't wait to see!

cabinfever · Mar 2, 2007

Zekers, i think your right. After I really scrutinized the tines i came up with about 25 inch MB. My orignal guess was 215 and I think he's closer to 208 gross. i also think i estimated a little to high on his G2's and mass, but not by much.

BLT · Mar 2, 2007

This is a tricky one guys.. In a hunting situation if you had your sights set to kill a 200" buck would he make the grade? or if you wanted a net book typical would he make it? this type of buck can be the hardest to judge, not to mention the early september cape and small ear set....Good luck. Paul Pennie

ansonlynn · Mar 2, 2007

I went in at 207 2/8 a few days ago. I'm pretty much in agreement with cabinfever, average mass and fantastic length - I'll throw in symmetry too. I don't mind being shown I'm way off base, but in my estimate this deer nets book.

Regarding the 200" question - I can only hold out for that if I get to include both the length and circumpherence of the woodie I'll be sportin' if I kill a buck like that!

ansonlynn · Mar 2, 2007

>I went in at 207 2/8
>a few days ago.
>I'm pretty much in agreement
>with cabinfever, average mass and
>fantastic length - I'll throw
>in symmetry too. I
>don't mind being shown I'm
>way off base, but in
>my estimate this deer nets
>book.
>
>Regarding the 200" question - I
>can only hold out for
>that if I get to
>include both the length and
>circumpherence of the woodie I'll
>be sportin' if I kill
>a buck like that!

DUH! Guess it was yesterday, seems like a long time ago ..

Nails · Mar 4, 2007

I'm thinking those are 1x6 planks, otherwise his chest cavity is only about 14" from back to brisket. The planks should be about 5" on the reveal. I am new to field judging, my guess was 212 6/8, might be on the high side but, i gotta learn somehow.

Gator · Mar 4, 2007

204 Very nice

Livetahunt · Mar 10, 2007

201 1/8

Chesterwyo · Mar 10, 2007

197 3/8

Tuffbucker · Mar 10, 2007

I guesses a few days ago and guessed the same thing as Chesterwyo....197 3/8....or was it 5/8.....shoot, now I dont remember.

Great buck and taxidermy!