dleonard3,
I understand where you are coming from, and if more spikes really turned into more big bulls I mihgt even agree with you.But first, although the overcrowding can be a problem near the roads, I have to say I never saw another hunter on foot the last two weekends. Sure, there were people riding around on ATVs, and plenty of archery deer hunters as well. And I even passed a few parked ATV's now and again, but I never saw another hunter. I don't think I interefered with a single LE hunter, although I'm sure it happens. My own personal expereince with an LE tag on the Monroe was impacted more by rifle hunters scouting for their upcoming hunt than the few general spike hunters present.
Back to the "more big bulls" statement. If the herd didn't have a high ratio of mature bulls, than letting the spikes all live might produce a few more mature bulls. That isn't the case onMonroe and many other LE units in Utah. Beyond a certain limit, you can't keep increasing the ratio of bulls to cows, and this led specifically to the introduction of management bull tags a few years ago. Several of our herds would be healthier with a bit fewer mature bulls in the herd. I wish it weren't so, as we would all love to see ratios of 2 bulls for every cow, but that just isn't the way nature works. Harvesting a few spikes each year can be good for the herd, as would culling a few inferior raghorns, but that is hard to manage. The added opportunity of the spike/cow hunt is good for the overall health of the herd, and the opportunity it provides.
And yes, I realize I probably won't change your mind.
Bill