First Tag... First Buck...

J

JustHuntn

Guest
Hello all...

Thought I would share with the MonsterMuley family my experience of tagging my first ever mule deer...

First, I would like to thank my Pops for everything he has ever taught me, and for "raising" me into the world of hunting...

My Dad and I have been putting in for this unit for 7 years and I finally drew it with 6 points. Pops should draw it next year. I told myself that I would hold out for something that would score at least 185-190, mainly because this was my first deer tag, and it took me seven years to draw it...

Saturday we looked over 8 bucks, but nothing in the ball park of what I was looking for. The next morning, we spotted another 9 bucks, bigger than the morning before, but still nothing that I was willing to pull the trigger on. Pops and I decided we would walk a ridge close to where we were seeing the majority of the deer?

We got about 15 minutes into the hike when we bumped what we thought were 4 does. We stopped and watched them as they watched us at about 75 yards. The front doe started to trot away, followed by the other three, but then out pops a buck as he followed behind them. We never seen him or even knew that he was there. He looked like a good buck, definitely bigger than anything we had already seen. To our surprise, all five deer stop, still at about 75 yards. I sit down, and steady myself on my shooting stick. The buck is standing broadside, looking at us, but he has 2 does between me and him. I look him over through my scope. I know he's the biggest we have seen yet, but I'm still not sure if he's what I'm looking for. By this time I've got the shakes pretty good, and my adrenaline is pumping by the gallons. I have a shot, but it's not the safest shot. Pops is to the right of me behind some scrub-oak, and can't see the buck. I sat there debating, should I shoot, should I shoot when they finally decided to move down hill. They weren't in a real hurry, and I had a clear broadside shot as he moved away, but I didn't shoot. I wasn?t 100% positive that he was what I was holding out for, so I passed. We sat for a minute to not spook them any further. As we sat there, I was beginning to feel regret for not taking him...

We decided to move to the top of the ridge to see where they were heading. We spotted them at the bottom of the ridge near a wide-open park, and watched them as they broke out into the wide open. This is when I realized how big of an idiot I was for not taking the shot. Out in the open he looked impressive. We watched them as they ran to the opposite side of the meadow into a small band of scrub-oak and pines, that was just below another large park. I high-tailed it down the ridge to circle around and get above them before they broke out into the other meadow. Pops stayed on the ridge where everything first took place to watch everything go down. I make it over to the higher park, above the band of trees I thought they were still in. As I make my way into the scrub-oak from above, I see the white of a deer face looking right at me. I freeze, and think to myself, what are the chances of me walking right in on 'em. I get down on my knees and look through the bino's to see if it was the buck or the does. It was definitely the buck, but he's got me pegged. Plus, where are the does? I'm sure they have me spotted too. I decided to scoot closer towards him on my knees using a small pine as cover hoping that he wouldn't spook. He's still staring straight at me, head-on at about 80 yards, and he's not budging. This stare-down lasts about 15-20 minutes before he finally relaxes and starts to feed again. I've had him my scope this whole time waiting for him to make that turn broadside. Finally he turns. Boom! "I can't believe it... He's down". One shot dropped him. I look across the open park to the ridge all this started on to see where Pops was. He was already moving towards me, smile ear to ear, and giving me a thumbs up. Pops finally gets over to me, and come to find out, he had been watching the buck the whole time, but had no idea where I was. Needless to say, I was pumped, Pops was pumped, and finally after 7 years, I have my first deer...

This buck was the 18th buck we had seen that weekend. Probably not the 185? deer I thought I would hold out for, but all that goes out the window when you've got your first big buck standing broadside to you in your scope. No official score on him yet, but I'm hoping he'll go 170-180. Whatever the score, I could not be happier with him as my first buck?

47420987566bc54e.jpg


47420a2f5b03ddc6.jpg


47420a565be91122.jpg


47420a6b5c4e6a59.jpg


47420a8a5cdde688.jpg


47420aa75d9a0a27.jpg
 
What an exciting hunt and story! You had my 'ol heart pumping too! Great job!

Eel

47421da752cfc54e.jpg


"hakuther rewyo hawten whanatay"..... Chief Little Turtle
 
What a wonderful first buck. How in the hell can a man wait 7 years to draw his first tag? I'm impressed with your patience. If I were you I'd pick up muzzleloader or archery hunting. Or go out of state. But to wait 7 years for your first tag???? I just couldn't do it. Good luck next year if your Dad draws a tag. I hope he gets a great buck like yours. fatrooster.
 
Thanks everyone... I appreciate the feedback...

Fatrooster... It was tough holding out for the tag... But wanted my first tag to be a good one... Now that I have drawn, and been successful, I will be goin archery next year... Drawing rifle deer tags in CO is tough, and I cant wait another 4-7 years for another good tag... So I'll be switching to archery for deer... That at worst, will put me on a every other year schedule for hunting deer in this area...

Again, thanks for the feedback fellas...

Also, do you guys think I am in the 170-180 ballpark with this buck... I lost close to 4"-5" in broken antler on him, but think he should still be in the 170-180 range...
 
167" hard to tell from a picture.
24" beam 15"-g2-7"g3-8"g4-3"g1 17" mass a side.
g2 broken on one side.
23" inside spread
Way nice buck whatever the score.
 
Hate to rain on your parade--and I wasn't going to say anything until you asked--but it looks like a 160 class buck to me. Still a fantastic first buck. I wouldn't worry about the score.
 
No worries SureShot... Like you said... I'm not gonna let the score bother me... Either way, I'm still pumped about him...
 
That's a great attitude. When you think, "This is when I realized how big of an idiot I was for not taking the shot. Out in the open he looked impressive." it's time to shoot. That's what hunting is all about.
 
Good job! That's a great buck! Good story too. Congrats on a great year - some things are worth waiting for!

UTROY
Proverbs 21:19 (why I hunt!)
 
score definitely does not matter. you had a very high quality hunt with your Dad and made an excellent shot on a good buck, that is what matters.

Congrats!
 
Nice buck and thanks for sharing. I think you were smart to save up your points and if I were you, I'd start saving again. Take up archery or put in for easy to get rifle tags while you build up your points and before long you'll have another great hunt in a limited area. I cashed in my 9 Res. deer points last year and never missed a season while accumulating the points.
 
Thanks again to everyone for all the kind words...

cobowhunter- I use that idea with Elk... We have hunted elk for the last 8-9 years without using one Preference Point and it has paid off... We should be hunting Bulls in Unit 76 first rifle season next year... Problem is that my elk hunt takes up all but 2 days of my vacation time here at work... So this area where I took my deer works out great, because it is only a 20 minute drive from my house... I have thought about starting all over again, but just don't think I can wait another 7 years now that I officially have the "Fever"... So I'm gonna give archery a shot... Alway wanted to try it, and think I have gotten good enough with my bow, so figured there is no better time to start than next year...

Thanks again to everyone, and I hope everybody has a happy Thanksgiving...
 
Well Sureshot... Looks like you are right on the button and I need to work on scoring Mule Deer...

Just got the call from the Taxi and he rough scored 161-7/8...

Either way though... He could've scored 140 and I'd still be happy with him... Thanks again everyone...
 
Great story, congratulations. I haven't got drawn for deer the last 4 years, in two states...but it never gets boring waiting when people keep posting these great hunts.

Thanks again,

Jim
 
I cant seem to break the 150 range! My 1st buck was a forkhorn whitey! You cant beat that. Like others have said I always build points while hunting 2nd choice or leftover deer tags. I have 7 points for elk and have been thinking about 76 but I am now a nonresident, maybe whenever we move back. I have a friend that has hunted 76 for 20 years (when they draw).
Congrats and thanks for sharing!


Jeff
 
Let us know what part of the state you live in and we can hook you up with a reputable archery shop so you can get off to a good start.

Great buck! Congratulations!
 

Click-a-Pic ... Details & Bigger Photos
Back
Top Bottom