Which Bull is Better? Taker? --- Question of the Day

Founder · Mar 30, 2015

Question of the Day ... Which bull is best? Which would you take?

I don't know elk too well, so what's your take on score of each of these bulls?

These photos are from our contributor Peter Eades. Great photos!

Brian Latturner
MonsterMuleys.com
Will you LIKE MonsterMuleys.com on Facebook! I need a friend....

Gator · Mar 30, 2015

Bull on the right. If the one on the left stepped out before the one on the right, I pull the trigger on either.

"I have found if you go the extra mile it's Never crowded".
>[Font][Font color = "green"]Life member of
>the MM green signature club.[font/]

stillwaitin · Mar 30, 2015

Bull on the right for sure. Seems to have longer beams, more mass and tine length. Both are beautiful bulls.

30Hart · Mar 30, 2015

One on right for sure...no question!

DW · Mar 30, 2015

I'm lousy at this game but 325 on the left 350 on the right?

nfh · Mar 30, 2015

LAST EDITED ON Mar-30-15 AT 01:02PM (MST)[p]The bull all around on the right is solid. Good fronts and good beams. has weak thirds but those thirds are a pretty standard length. Other than that no complaints on the bull on the right.

The left bull is missing on brow tine on the right antler. weak fronts. Younger bull. weak royals. Still a decent bull. I like his longer back points. Mass is weak compared to the bull on the right.

left bull 320
right bull-345-355

heartshot · Mar 30, 2015

left bull 290-300
right bull-???? but definitely bigger

Deerlove · Mar 30, 2015

I agree with Dan, bull on the left about 300 bull on right 330 340.

Zeke · Mar 30, 2015

Bull on right.
Yes, he's a "taker", "keeper", "shooter" or whatever else you want to call him.
I'd say "boom".
Zeke

SPAZ · Mar 30, 2015

David on the left, goliath on the right. They aren't even close in size. gross on the left will be lucky to be 280 with the missing tine - net way lower than that. The bull on the right is a nice one, 340 range I'd guess.

huntin50 · Mar 30, 2015

the one on the left is 270 to 280 bull. A young bull with short tines and little mass.

Bull on the right 340 type bull. Longer tines, more mass, beam length, spread.

rmanwill · Mar 30, 2015

Bull on right.

PSC_bears17 · Mar 30, 2015

The bull on the right....

cmbbulldog · Mar 30, 2015

The bull on the right has to be close to 40 inches better than the bull on the left, maybe more.

elkassassin · Mar 30, 2015

Neither one!

Both PISSCUTTERS!

We laugh, we cry, we love
Go hard when the going's tough
Push back, come push and shove
Knock us down, we'll get back up again and again
We are Members of the Huntin Crowd!

crownroyal · Mar 31, 2015

bull on left does it even have a G2 on his right side??

Left bull no way.. 300-305

Right bull would have me lookin. 340-345 tough to pass

BrowningRage · Mar 31, 2015

I agree with many above. The bull on the left isn't even a 300" bull.

The bull on the right is gonna go 340-350...

Bull on the right...

"Therefore, wo be unto him that is at ease in Zion!" 2 Ne. 28: 24

bownanza332 · Mar 31, 2015

Not even a question. Bull on the right is better in every category.... Length, mass and he has all of his points. Plus, I love those dark antlers. I say he is 340+. The left bull will have a hard time reaching the 300 mark.

hank4elk · Mar 31, 2015

Agreed,right is way better , 340+
Left maybe 290.

eldorado · Mar 31, 2015

The bull on the right. But I wouldn't hesitate to pull the trigger on the other bull.

Eldorado

PointHunter · Mar 31, 2015

Bull on the right fits my eye

Cass · Mar 31, 2015

Seein as how everyone is shooting the one on the right i probably wont get a chance so i'll give some love to the left one

-Cass

rockn9858 · Apr 1, 2015

Bull on the right, more mass and over all longer points.

Alamosa · Apr 24, 2015

The bull on the right.
Look at the bodies. I like that sagging back and pot belly that the mature bulls get. The bull om the left looks thin - like he could use another year to bulk up and mature. I like the longer mane (right) too.

I like the white polished antler tips on the one on the left but that is all. Almost every antler point is larger on the one on the right.

Schleppy · Apr 25, 2015

The one on the right appears to be a 6x8 and looks pretty long with good mass. I would say 350+ and a definite shooter. The one on the left needs to keep growing, it would be interesting to see how his left antler developes, it doesn't look broken but it is growing funny...

Buglelk · Apr 28, 2015

the one on the right all day long I like the whale tale look much much better.

CAelknuts · May 1, 2015

I'll put this in a bit different light. While we all agree that the bull on the right is clearly the bigger bull, stop and think about this...

Either bull is bigger than many elk hunters will ever kill in their lifetime. Lots of elk hunters never kill a 300" bull in all their years of hunting.