Where do you stand?

browtine

Super Moderator
Messages
4,887
This came from ksl.com
http://www.ksl.com/?nid=148&sid=2640092

The plight of thousands of starving deer and elk has triggered an emotional debate between people who want to feed them and state wildlife officials who say it's a bad idea.

The state did begin emergency feeding last weekend, so why can't concerned citizens? Experts worry that residents who see starving animals near their homes, will do the feeding in the wrong way, in the wrong place.

Everyone agrees it's one of the toughest winters in years. That's why a huge herd of about 200 elk took up residence right in the city of Heber. Volunteers have been putting out hay to feed them.



In Morgan County, hundreds of deer are wandering in populated places. They often crowd around ornamental shrubs and start chomping desperately. People who see them struggling often feel strongly that where the state isn't feeding them, homeowners should.

Buzz Burgener, a volunteer feeder, said, "Would you rather see them in your backyard alive? Or would you rather see them dead?"

Another volunteer feeder, Darlene Musselman, said, "We need to help them when they're in dire need, and right now they are really in dire need."

The Utah Division of Wildfire Resources has launched feeding programs in only a few places. They discourage people from doing it themselves.

Phil Douglass, with the Utah Division of Wildlife Resources, said, "It's not a matter of just throwing out food. It's a matter of transitioning these animals onto the artificial feed and being able to have a combination of natural feed as well. That's ultimately what we'd like to see."

The Division says picking the wrong place can create hazards by luring animals across highways. It can also lead to conflicts with homeowners who don't want them and dogs that often chase them.

It's a complex argument, and the division is having some trouble selling it this year.

Elk and deer are not the only big animals trying to find food. Moose are also getting hungry. A rancher began feeding one hungry bull, but now it won't leave.

Rancher Burliee Graham says a young moose has taken over the ranch, and no matter what they do, it keeps coming back.

Ranch foreman, Burliee Graham, said, "Sometimes he blocks me from getting to the horses. This morning he run me out right back through the gate behind us. He's kind of adopted the area here, so we're trying to work around him the best we can."

Despite the nuisance, Graham says he hopes they won't need wildlife officials to step in.






buck1.gif


Later, Brandon
 
Its a tough call. They definitely need feed, but we don't need some yahoo out there trying to give them whatever crap they can find. DWR needs to step up its program! Tack on $1 to every Deer tag and that should cover it.
 
LAST EDITED ON Feb-10-08 AT 07:26PM (MST)[p]Maybe if that moose (or any of these critters being fed by the public) hurts or worse kills some one, the general public will get it through their thick skulls that " IN THE RIGHT PLACE " isn't their backyards and that it might be better to let the Division do their jobs!

Its great that they want to help. donate time and/or money, under the umbrella of the DWR, thats the best case senerio.

EDIT* If any of these critters does hurt a citizen what are the odds they'll sue the DWR for not having a feeding station set up away from their house?
47aa8a9e202b0d9f.jpg
 
There is plenty of talk going around about this issue, the fact of the matter is the critters need our help. Personally, I wonder if permanent feeding stations that are set in areas where the critters can get to them and be away from the majority of homes is something that needs to be done. We have used up all the winter range for our homes, so why can't we "create" feeding stations? I am helping with 2 feeding stations here and we are currently seeing 70-110 turkeys and 50-70 deer. They are feeding where in the past they have been fed before. I'm just a simple guy, but it seems to make sense to me. We have permanent areas to feed the elk, hardware ranch, millville face, why not do the same for deer.

It would make counting and monitoring the herd alot easier wouldn't it? Maybe control poaching more? The coyotes would also be drawn to these areas and would be easier to thin out. I just wonder, with all of us on MM, do you think the DWR ever reads some of the ideas we have? Expressing our thoughts about the problems our state has is thearaputic, but what does it really do for the animals?
 

Click-a-Pic ... Details & Bigger Photos
Back
Top Bottom