Nice buck, how big?

[hunt7112]

I have a chance at either of these bucks I think I like this first one better but don't know if he would score higher what would this one score. Thanks. This picture is about 3 weeks old he may have picked up a little size by now.

 

[legacy]

#1 would score higher - I like #1 better regardless of score.

 

[UTmonsterslayer]

Hands down, buck number one would score better and looks better. He is better in every aspect of what makes a good buck, except width, but who cares about that. Smoke #1 and show us a pic! Good luck.

 

[SureShot]

I agree the 1st one is better, but I would be taking whichever one presented the first shot opportunity.

 

[NVMULEDEER1]

No doubt #1.....Lets see those pictures when he hits the ground!

 

[Stubaby]

LAST EDITED ON Aug-27-09 AT 04:14PM (MST)[p]Number one...no brainer....too bad you can't wait till he scrapes off....those kickers bases are gonna look cool as heck when its all bone.

 

[ADDICT]

#1 is a very big deer man. That buck will score extremely well! Those are huge eyeguards, great beams, long tines, symmetrical and 4-5" of extras. I think he would gross 185"?

All of those bucks look good though. I hope you take one. Looks like Kaibab somewhere

 

[ADDICT]

LAST EDITED ON Aug-27-09 AT 09:50PM (MST)[p]Circumferences add up on him too! Put him down!

 

[hunt7112]

Thanks for the input, I will be hunting these deer starting on Monday. I will be holding out for buck #1 hopefully I will have photos of him on the ground. Thanks good luck to all.

 

[Rodent_ID]

I would try for #1 but if shot wasnt there couldnt be disapointed with #2....good luck

 

[HiMtnHntr]

I think #1 is a 190" deer!

 

[JamesM]

Both are good loking bucks, I would be pleased with either one. Number one has more charecter so I say number one for sure.

 

[cmbbulldog]

I was thinking buck number 1 was around 190 as well. Great eye guards and really cool looking buck. Let us know when you put him on the ground. Good luck.

 

[west]

I would shoot whichever one of those bucks walked into range first.


"blaming guns for violence is like blaming spoons for Rosie O'donnell being fat."