WHICH BUCK, 40 WIDE OR 200 INCHES GR

I'll take the wide one please :)

Nothing the matter with the other buck, in fact i'd love to let the air outa him but side by side, 40" is awful unusual and would be near impossible to ever get again.

Joey
 
Your sick Yelum, Sick!!!! That question is like asking "Do you want a threesome with 2 blondes or 2 Brunettes"? I dont know but they both look good to me. 40 incher for me if I have to decide though.....Dang it!
 
Cjboz
So you would have a problem choosing between Pro and Slammy in one bed and Founder and Feleno in the other? lol

Now who's the sick one.
Yelum
 
LAST EDITED ON Sep-09-09 AT 02:54PM (MST)[p]YOU STILL!!! LMAO

I did not waste my 1000th Post on this thread. It was used as best as it could, Thanks for the Big bucks to bust my cherry on!!!:)
 
both are nice bucks
But i think you'd be real disappointed when you stretched the tape on that 40 incher & found out he is slightly short of 40
not trying to make anybody mad but when most see, if they ever see a 40 incher they're gonna swear its a 50 incher

we are YoungCountry, we like all kinds
of music and people, 'cause we do draw some lines'
no our hair is not orange,we don't wear chains and spikes
but we know how to have fun come Saturday night
 
>If it was the last day
>of your limited entry hunt,
>and you had these two
>bucks side by side.
>Which one would you take?


I would shoot either one on the first day of the hunt...LOL :)

"A well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed."
 
Last day, first day... Makes no difference. I would kill either of them, but the 200 incher would be my first choice.
 
hell both are awesome bucks even the smaller of the two in the second video is a good buck!! i would be like a 5 year old in a candy store in that situation. but probably would have to go with the wide one, he's got some character to him!!! cool post






"Shoot Strait"
 
40"er for me. Never seen one that wide, don't suppose I ever will either.


2a0fcsk.gif
 
YoungCountry
With all the video and pics we got of this buck, and putting his sheds on a skull, we're pretty sure he's right about 42 inches wide. He's easily wider than the 38 inch buck I have mounted.

cjboz, congrats on the 1000. I wasted my 1000 on a dumb post as well. :)

As for me, I would also take the 200. His beams are 28+ and he looks great.

Yelum
 
200" deer are rare indeed but A 40"er is even more rare. I'd kill the 40"er even though I like the 200"er better. Then I'd keep trying to kill a 200"er in my future. fatrooster.
 
Neither one of them is all that pretty... As such, it's just a width competition so I would shoot the 40"... A better looking 200" buck would get me going, but not that one...
 
The second one.....now if the cage was 40" wide and not just the cheaters sticking east and west....then you would have popeye back on the hoof....
 
Throughout the mule deer range their are a many 200 inch deer. Fourty inchers are not common....so I'll take the fourty incher and his less than 200 inch rack!
 
its good to see that this wide one is still alive and I have a shed from his right side from about 4to5 years ago. When we watched him in 2007 he was 38 to 40 wide then and his hammers have gotten longer. on-target
 
LAST EDITED ON Sep-09-09 AT 10:20PM (MST)[p]I've never seen a 40 incher, but have killed a handful of 200+ inchers. I'd take the 40 incher....super rare they are!!!

Thanks a bunch for sharing the clips Larry. Sure fun to see.

Brian Latturner
MonsterMuleys.com
 
200 fer me....

------------------------------------------------------
"Yeah, I'll shoot him"
 
It wouldn't matter. If I saw those two side by side I'd have keeled over and died and not been able to take either one.
 
I myself would have to say the 40" buck, I am always a fan of huge forks but the matching forked cheaters on the G2 give him some sweet character and I think he would pretty sick on the wall!!!
 
I would have to go with the 40 incher. 200 inchers are a dime a dozen these days but a 40 incher now thats rare!
 
Old school here ..... width wins the whole shooting match in my book, as long as its not willowy. He's NOT willowy, so he gets his air let out pronto. Scores are for football, I want something that I can't wait to see every day on my office wall....something that keeps me from working, something very distracting. He fits the bill. Can I have his GPS coordinates?
 
I'm with most of the others. That width would be impossible to ever match. To me mass is most important but width is next. Both are shooters anywhere with exception of governors tags.
 
I would choose the 40 wide. I would then clean the 200 inch skid mark in my drawers.

30-30
 

Click-a-Pic ... Details & Bigger Photos
Back
Top Bottom