score contest 10

[monarchtaxidermy]

Isn't there something about those big bucks!!! I just love them. This weeks contest brings us back to mule deer. I have pictures of two bucks we just finished. For this contest you are guessing the combined gross score for both bucks and adding them together to get one score. Example if i think one buck scored 155and the other buck scored 160 then my guess would be 315. After you have put your combined score down, I would like each member say which of the 2 they would rather shoot if they had a choice. You will get 1 photo with the 2 bucks together to see how they compare. Then you will get 1 photo of each buck

One last example

Buck 1 score 155
buck 2 Score 165
Combined score 320

I would shoot the buck on the right!!!!! I like the tall ones.

Good Luck

Rules

1. Only 1 guess per MM Member
2. 1st correct combined gross score wins
3. If no correct gross combined score is guessed, then the next closest score wins
4. contest will end the Night of July 5th

This weeks winner will recieve a beautiful slanted plaque to mount a euro on, and a couple cabelas t-shirts

Thanks for Playing
Curtis Wilson

 

[Horniac]

Buck 1 178
Buck 2 188

Combined 366

I would shoot buck #2

Thanks for all the scoring contests!

Horniac

 

[Devlin]

Buck 1 181 Buck 2 171 Gross 352 and I would shoot # 1

 

[Trix4me]

Buck 1 173
Buck 2 177
Total 350
I'd shoot #1

 

[muleyhunter413]

Combined score of 359. Buck on the left 177. Buck on the right 182. I would take the buck on the left due to the fact that I have a few that are tall and narrow. Also i love his mass and eyeguards. Thanks for giving us something to play..

 

[Gator]

178 & 181 total 359 and I would shoot the 1st one like them wide.


"I have found if you go the extra mile it's Never crowded".

 

[BBB]

351

1st deer 174
2nde deer 177

I would shoot the tall one for its character!

 

[soupcreek]

Buck #1 = 166
Buck #2 = 172
Total score: 338
Do I get anything for having actually been to Monarch, MT? Its a great place. I did some land surveying over there a few years ago. Beautiful country around there.
Soup

 

[nvhunter]

left 179" right 171" total 349" i would shoot the one on the left for sure

 

[NEVADAGUY]

Buck #1 - 175 3/8
Buck #2 - 182 1/8
Total - 357 4/8

I'd shoot buck #2.

 

[bucksmut]

Buck on the right 162 and 4/8

Buck on the left 172 and 5/8

Total gross score 335 and 1/8

I would go for the one on the left as I love the eyegaurds and I bowhunt and think this would look like a pig in velvet Thanks !

 

[nmbighorn]

368 and I would shoot the one on right

 

[buckspotter7]

#1 - 177 3/8
#2 - 163 4/8

Total 340 7/8

the wider one

 

[buckmaster_wa]

Buck 1 is 168
Buck 2 is 177
Total is 345

I would shoot the buck on the left. I like the dark antlers and the eyeguards.

 

[ICMDEER]

346 anda 6/8. And I'd shoot the one on the left; no doubt. I already have one that is almost exactly like the buck on the right.

 

[hornkiller]

left 174
right 168
total 342

 

[DKMULEYBUCK]

164 1/8, 167 7/8 Total 332

Whichever one gave a clear shot first, but only on the last couple of days

 

[northernNMhtr]

339 5/8

 

[mntman]

369 1/8, I wouldn't have a choice cause I wouldn't wait for the second one to come out for comparison.
Mntman

"Hunting is where you prove yourself"

 

[YELUM]

LAST EDITED ON Jun-28-10 AT 07:22AM (MST)[p]181
165
----
346

I like the looks of the top buck and would shoot him on most hunts. I would pass on the lower buck on all hunts.

How do you like the new eyes you use forr these mounts?


Yelum

 

[IdahoBugler]

buck #1 168 2/8"
buck #2 161 1/8"
Combined 329 3/8"

Both bucks are nice but nothing completes a muley more then eye-guards for me. I guess I've shot to many without or with just one. I'd go with buck #1.

 

[huntindad4]

I will say....

163 for the buck on the left

159 for the buck on the right

322 total

and although I like height I would shoot the left buck as he has enough height and some width and mass.

Bill

 

[HuntinFool]

310

 

[1hooper]

156 166 322 I LIKE THE BUCK ON RIGHT I WOULD SHOOT HIM.

 

[GoatT]

Buck 1 - 176 3/8
Buck 2 - 178 1/8
Total - 354 4/8

I would take the second buck.

 

[magnum300ultra]

BUCK #1 167
BUCK #2 162

TOTAL 329 I WOULD TAKE BUCK #2

 

[NvrEnuf]

GoatT you took my exact guess so I'm going to round down...

176
178

354 even.

NvrEnuf

 

[lbeaumont11]

182 & 187 5/8 = 369 5/8

I'd shoot the one on the left for width.

 

[sneekeepete]

Wide Buck 166 Tall buck 173 Total 339
I'd shoot the tall buck .

 

[jdh]

Buck #1 166"
Buck #2 172"

Total...338"

jdh
www.muleyphotos.com

 

[jdh]

Whoops just noticed I posted the same as someone else Sorry

Buck #1 166.5
Buck #2 172.5

Total...339

jdh
www.muleyphotos.com

 

[curlybill]

345 2/8. I would take the one on the right.

 

[JACO]

332 3/8, I would shoot the wider one, I like the looks of it better.

Nocked N Loaded

 

[tedcrf450]

Buck #1 = 170
Buck #2 = 177
Total = 347

I'd hit first one like em wide.

 

[Pines_N_Tines]

Buck #1 = 173 1/8"
Buck #2 = 169 5/8"

Total Guess = 342 6/8"

I'd shoot buck number 1. If I can't have both height and width, I'll take width. Buck number one has better mass and has good looking symmetry.

Nice looking wall pedastal mounts done on each of these bucks.

 

[KaibabHntr]

#1: 168
#2: 173
_________
341

I'd take #1.

Ryan
www.KeyToTheKaibab.com

 

[Deerlove]

171 1/4 on the first and 175, 346 1/2 I'd shoot the second buck

 

[heartshot]

367 7/8

I would should shoot th wide one. He looks better and his back end is just as tall as the the other one.

 

[BrowningRage]

Buck #1 Score- 173 1/8
Buck #2 Score- 164 1/8

Combined- 337 2/8

Standing next to one another, I'd drop the wider of the two... But later I'd regret it and dream of that tall buck until I got mine back from the Taxi...


"Therefore, wo be unto him that is at ease in Zion!" 2 Ne. 28: 24

 

[gunguy]

buck #1 172 3/8
buck #2 175 4/8
total 347 7/8
If these bucks are in oregon I'D SHOOT ether one in a heartbeat!
like those tall horns the best.

 

[Snuffy]

358

 

[zekers]

340 3/8, first buck.

 

[nripepi]

352. I would shoot either, but if I had to pick one, I would go with the wide one on the left.

 

[desertbonehunter]

LAST EDITED ON Jun-28-10 AT 04:48PM (MST)[p]1st 170 4/8
2nd 175
total 345 1/2
I would shoot the one on the far left you can only see one side of

 

[grizzly]

343 2/8

The one on the left, I like the width more than length.

Grizzly

 

[Maverickt]

Buck 1 Score 174
Buck 2 Scor 180
Combined score 354
I would shoot the buck on the left.

 

[cjboz]

174 #1
163 #2
337 TOTAL

buck 1 as my choice, love his deep tines and symmetry.

Thanks for the contest

 

[NVMDF]

168" each.
336" total

NVMDF

 

[Romulus]

Buck 1 173 5/8 Buck 2 172 total 345 5/8 I would shoot buck 1.

 

[fishfurlife]

183 1/8
167 3/8

Total

350 4/8

 

[cmbbulldog]

347 1/4. I would shoot the 1st buck.

 

[buckmster28]

344 7/8 and I'd shoot the first one.

 

[wildsage]

376 5/8 I would shoot the 2nd one

 

[huntinfanatic]

LAST EDITED ON Jun-28-10 AT 06:46PM (MST)[p]169 1/8 tall narrow buck
177 wider buck with eye guards
346 1/8 total
I would shoot the wider one any day over the tall narrow buck.

 

[Schleppy]

341 3/8, I would shoot either one!

 

[coyoteslayer]

356 3/8

tall one 172
wide one 184ish
shoot the wide one for sure.

 

[sagebucks]

340 1/8 #1 172 1/8 #2 168 I would shoot #1

 

[txhunter58]

Wider buck outscores the tall buck by a little. 335 total score

txhunter58

venor, ergo sum (I hunt, therefore I am)

 

[mr_c]

#1 left buck 165 6/8 #2 right buck 169 7/8 my choice would be the macho buck on leftside

 

[mr_c]

darnett 335 6/8

 

[Browningbar23]

323

 

[Twoshooter]

356 2/8 combined. I would shoot the wide one even though I think the narrow one will score better.

 

[ridgetops]

349 3/8

I would shoot the one one the left. I like the squared off box look.

 

[chasendeer]

353 3/8
Jay

 

[sarg7mm]

168 and 167 total 335
they are both similar in score "i believe" but i would shoot the wide one he just looks better, and its not because of his width.

 

[knoxville471]

362 i wouldn't shoot either of them because i would be at full draw scratchin my head wondering which to shoot as they busted down the hill

 

[never_catch]

I'll guessssstimate 175 1/8" on the wide buck and 162" even on the tall buck for a total of 337 1/8".

Wide one is better looking IMO...

~Z~

 

[7remmag]

1-169 4/8
2-166 3/8
total: 335 7/8

Both nice bucks...

 

[Show_Me_Your_Rack]

1st---183
2nd---172 3/8
Total---355 3/8

YOU AINT GOING TO KILL A BIG BUCK UNLESS THERE IS A BIG BUCK WHERE YOUR HUNTING!!!

 

[huntmancam]

Buck #1 176
Buck #2 169

Combined Score: 345

I'd shoot the left buck for sure

 

[mike111]

Buck #1: 176
Buck #2: 184

Combined Score: 360

I would shoot buck #2 good tine length

 

[T_Ball]

#1 Buck 189 1/8
#2 Buck 185 7/8
Total 375

I would shoot buck #1.

 

[HICntryCO]

#1- 178 1/8
#2- 188 3/8

Total 366 4/8


I'd take #2, I like the tall look and his deeper forks and better fronts might make up for anything he loses in width.

 

[travishunter3006]

178 2/8

172 4/8

350 6/8

 

[Elkaholic26]

294 6/8 the one on the right for me.

 

[elknr]

374 is my total for both.And i would shoot the wide one.

 

[StickFlinger]

1 - 172 6/8 + 170 3/8 = 343 1/8
I would shoot either one if they were alone. Wide one if they were together.

 

[swbuckmaster]

166
171
total 337

one on the right. I want a tall buck and I think it might score better.

Nets are for fish!!

 

[wetworn]

buck #1 178
buck #2 182

 

[kzkammo]

I'd say 353

 

[nmhunter01]

343 3/8 I'd take buck 2

 

[chase]

349 6/8 i would shoot the right one, nice forks

 

[ORIONTHEHUNTER]

360 I would shoot the one on left, I like width

 

[Smokepole]

334 total - I'd shoot the wide one #1, I already have one that is tall like #2

Smokepole

 

[bucksandducks]

Buck number 1 163
Buck number 2 170
Total 333

I would shot both of them I would rather shoot Buck number 2

 

[Shotgun59]

344

170 Left
174 Right
I would shoot #2 to match the 170 I already have, twins would look kind of cool.

 

[fuzzyvelvet]

337 7/8 total score. I would take the one on the left.

 

[muleyskinner]

top 173 bottom 165 total 338
I would shoot them both but I would preffer the top buck

 

[rackman]

191 I would shoot the one on the left!

 

[dogbreath]

331 3/8

 

[jabber]

333 4/8

I would take the wider one.

 

[liecabucks]

164 6/8 on the left one, 172 on the right one. So 336 6/8 and I think i would tag the wider one.


Sit tall in the saddle, hold your head up high, keep your eyes fixed to where the trail meets the sky...

 

[AZ_TXhunter]

331 6/8 #2

 

[piper]

341 1/8

 

[orion23]

356

Travis
www.RidgelineOutdoors.com
Blacks-Creek Pack Dealer

 

[excaliber]

L 171 5/8 R 175 1/8 346 3/4 I'd take the one on the left

 

[Blackjack]

172
178
Total 350
Shoot the one on the right

 

[TheKnack]

total=360 5/8
Just a guess

 

[theox]

351 2/8

i like wider bucks so id shoot the wider one

 

[Tsho86]

338 3/8