Who's good at scoring velvet bucks?

muleymaster · Aug 7, 2011

I have three videos of three different bucks i videoed this year up scouting for the Idaho general archery season. Im not the best at scoring yet so i thought id see what you guys think?? enjoy

thanks

Video 1

Video 2

Video 3

SageHunter29 · Aug 7, 2011

Those are some nice bucks! I would love to shoot one like that buck in the 2nd video some day. Got to love the tall and narrow bucks.

AZ4life · Aug 7, 2011

I'm thinking 160s for the first guy, no idea for the second guy with the 15inch spead haha, and maybe 150 for the third?

IDmuleyman · Aug 7, 2011

Those are all some nice bucks, I think they are all around the same size... High 150s to mid 160s with the last one maybe a little better.

TOPGUN · Aug 7, 2011

1st---Maybe 160"
2ond---?
3rd---150" at best

marley · Aug 7, 2011

1st buck: 163"
2nd buck: ??
3rd buck: 166"

Stubaby · Aug 7, 2011

First 163

2nd...don't matter. Hate the narrow ones. They gotta be at least 24"

3rd....I'll give him 171. I think that front end will score better than you would think. Lots of curl to the main beams and decent g4s. Either way pretty and deserving of an arrow almost anywhere.

"That's a special feeling, Lloyd"

one_dryboot · Aug 7, 2011

1st and 3rd bucks will go 160's 3rd buck being the biggest

ADDICT · Aug 8, 2011

The first buck scores the best. 160 ish. Great beams and looks pretty heavy. Those bucks with the big front ends really add up.

Narrows is cool as hell. Id shoot him just because.

The last one has a ton of potential! Hes probably in the 160 range as well but needs 2 years.

Great video--thanks for posting!

"You skin grizz?"

muleymaster · Aug 8, 2011

Thanks for the help. And its preseason scouting. Meaning they will loose thier velvet before season and even if they didnt, what difference does it make. They all eat the same. I feel that was an ignorant comment and an unwanted one on this site.

ADDICT · Aug 8, 2011

What a crock. This site is all about hunters sharing pics/stories etc. I wish guys would just chill out and keep the negativity off the site. It doesnt benefit anyone.

muleymaster-- Thanks for the taking the time to upload those videos and post them. I thought they were great deer and a lot of fun to see. I appreciated it man.

Good luck this month--hope you STICK one!

"You skin grizz?"

74cj5 · Aug 8, 2011

Thanks for your post and great videos! It's a shame that there is always some loser looking for an argument. Your videos are what this site is all about!

Great bucks, I'd happily draw back on any one... And then would probably miss!

BrowningRage · Aug 9, 2011

Great deer for any tag- let alone public land archery.

1st buck is 158"

2nd buck is 156" (He's got better backs than #1, but the spread is dismal)

3rd buck looks to go about 165"

They're all shooters with my bow, that's for sure.

"Therefore, wo be unto him that is at ease in Zion!" 2 Ne. 28: 24

muleymaster · Aug 9, 2011

thanks a lot guys! post some of your own videos and pics so i have something to drool over till season haha

TOPGUN · Aug 10, 2011

This is unreal that a simple thread with someone asking for a few guesses on scores of 3 bucks has resulted in a number of posts being removed! Why don't a few of these members grow up or find another site to take their negativity to!!!