His will score better because of deeper forks, but if they were standing side by side, I think I would shoot hers. Just a more mature looking deer with more mass.
That said, just keep saying her bucks are bigger, but if she ever asks you if something else of hers is bigger, the answer is always NO.
Great buck arae13 and welcome to monstermuleys! With a 300 yard shot and a bow shot, it would also be hard to say who had the most difficult! Congrats to you both!
txhunter58
venor, ergo sum (I hunt, therefore I am)