Two Four Points

idsharp · Jul 15, 2017

Here's two four point bucks. One is narrow with longer tines while the other is wide with shorter tines. Both are good mature deer in a general archery unit.
Which one would you take? Why? Score?
https://youtu.be/Zi8yLZsJm6s
Let me know if the link doesn't work.

pushin_30 · Jul 15, 2017

Both are great general unit bucks? 155-165 class the wider, heavier one still looks like he's got some growing to do. he might end up a 170. I have a hard time passing on bucks like these with a bow. So I'd be happy with either going on my wall

Mnbearhunter123 · Jul 15, 2017

Yeah..I would bet The wider shorter buck will finish out quite a bit better than the narrower buck when they're hard horned. Both are awesome bucks. I wouldn't pass either in my archery area. Good Luck!

Mnbearhunter123 · Jul 15, 2017

LAST EDITED ON Jul-15-17 AT 12:29PM (MST)[p]Almost forgot...my guess when they finish out..
Narrow buck @ 165
Wider buck @ 175

Cooper · Jul 15, 2017

Those are great bucks, let us know after you get one, good luck ?

Joe2Kool · Jul 15, 2017

Both standing at 20 yards broadside and a choice, I'd shoot the wide one. Both wandering around together like in the video, I'd shoot the first one that gave me a good shot.

Score? IDK. Unfortunately not enough experience on my part with deer that size!