I'll be getting my archery bull scored this week by a P&Y measurer. I also was going to put it in the B&C book. The question is, do I have to have a seperate person score it for each book, or should the P&Y scorer be able to enter one score under both books? I've looked through the P&Y/B&C books and have noticed some guys scores are the same and some are a few inches different..looks like some guys had seperate scorers, and some had the same scorer. If possible it would be better to have one score for both books. The P&Y measure that I'll be taking it too says he only will be able to do a score for P&Y, and if I want to put the elk in B&C I'll have to have a B&C person also score it. Thanks for any info.
P&Y/B&C Elk
- Thread starter mike111
- Start date
BOHNTR
Long Time Member
- Messages
- 4,339
Mike:
That is correct. If you have a P&Y measurer score your elk and and it nets high enough for B&C also, you'll need to have it re-measured by an official B&C measurer for their respective club.
However, P&Y will accept an official B&C entry, so if you can have it scored by a B&C measurer, you can enter into both clubs providing it meets the minimum score and fair chase rules are from each club were adhered to.
There are several reasons why some official scores are slightly different for the two clubs. Many times the socre is lower for P&Y than B&C simply because the animal that makes B&C is usually large enough in P&Y that it requires a panel measurement. Generally, panel measurements are slightly lower than an individual measurers tally, as all three have to agree on the measurements and markings taken.
Hope it helps and congrats on what sounds like a terrific trophy.
BOHNTR )))---------->
That is correct. If you have a P&Y measurer score your elk and and it nets high enough for B&C also, you'll need to have it re-measured by an official B&C measurer for their respective club.
However, P&Y will accept an official B&C entry, so if you can have it scored by a B&C measurer, you can enter into both clubs providing it meets the minimum score and fair chase rules are from each club were adhered to.
There are several reasons why some official scores are slightly different for the two clubs. Many times the socre is lower for P&Y than B&C simply because the animal that makes B&C is usually large enough in P&Y that it requires a panel measurement. Generally, panel measurements are slightly lower than an individual measurers tally, as all three have to agree on the measurements and markings taken.
Hope it helps and congrats on what sounds like a terrific trophy.
BOHNTR )))---------->
MEANTTOBBUCK
Active Member
- Messages
- 464
Mike111,
Did I miss your post with a picture of your bull and story? What unit did you get him in?
Did I miss your post with a picture of your bull and story? What unit did you get him in?
