Well, I did not shoot or see an elk in Colorado GMU 75. I'm was a first time elk hunter, and I think my failure was probably due to my rookie mistakes, some I have identified and others yet unperceived by me.
My Plan A was to backpack into the Weminuche Wilderness area and hunt around treeline. 8" to 10" of snow was on the ground when I backpacked in, making the going difficult and discouraging me from going in as deeply as I planned. On opening morning snow started at 4 AM and continued all day, which led me to decide to pack out to avoid getting stuck until spring up there. So, my Plan A got flushed and I had no Plan B!!! A big mistake there.
I hunted the remaining 4 days of the Colorado first rifle elk season driving up the road, finding a "likely spot," parking the truck, climbing up the ridge, and looking for elk. I saw lots of sign -- fresh elk tracks (there was new snow almost every night), elk droppings, elk beds, a rub -- so I felt I was at the right elevation and generally around the elk, just didn't see the elk. I left early several evenings, before the end of legal shooting light and got out late several mornings. I think these were mistakes that reduced my chances of success, and I won't make this mistake next time.
I found some very fresh elk tracks one morning -- crossed fresh tracks about 30 minutes after a very heavy snowfall, had to be less than 30 minutes old. I followed these tracks up with energy and speed but wore out before I found the elk. I'm thinking maybe my method was wrong, that speed wasn't what was needed, that maybe the elk saw me and walked just fast enough to keep in front of me. Any recommendations about what I should have done when I came across these 30 minute old elk tracks, at about 10 AM??? Follow up slow, glassing ahead a lot? What does the experienced elk hunter do in this circumstance?
I spent a late afternoon and an early morning hidden on the edge of a small park that was surrounded by dark timber, hidden from the road, with a small stream on one edge. I was waiting in ambush for an elk to show up. Is this sometimes a productive strategy or is this a low probability action?