Any teachers here?

feddoc

Long Time Member
Messages
7,221
Schoolhousegrizz????


Do you see this at your school?



(more at the link)


While a world without textbooks or homework and where getting the wrong answer is celebrated may sound like an elementary student’s fantasy, that becoming reality would damage a generation of young minds. However, that is exactly what is happening in public elementary schools.

I recently spoke with a fourth grade teacher from the midwest, who shared her experiences of curriculum shifting from history and science and towards political indoctrination, to the detriment of students’ learning. For this person’s privacy, she will remain nameless.


In supervising fourth grade, she teaches a little of everything: math, reading, language arts, social studies, and science. Recently her school district, like many others, switched to “integrated curriculum.”

On paper, an integrated curriculum sounds like a fair idea: learning subjects by exploring their intersections to deepen understanding. However, in practice, the curriculum all but eradicates history, and works to push politics on impressionable children.

The teacher said, “It says ‘integrated curriculum,’ and some of its science, and some of its social studies but it really isn’t. It’s more of a push for the progressive movement.” Her curriculum was fundamentally altered by it. The school district’s new curricula is online, gives outsiders the ability to dictates curriculum to teachers. This teacher’s science and history classes were gutted.
 
Last edited:
I work at a middle school as a special education teacher. I teach mostly 7th graders on my case load but I am also the behavioral "specialist." (if you will) I deal with all of the behavioral problems in a title 1 school with a population of around 975 students.
My wife teaches at a title 1 elementary school. She teaches 2nd grade.
The article is very ambiguous. Every school district changes their curriculum. Is she talking about remote learning or general education before all of this crap (covid) went down?
In elementary, there is hardly any science or social studies being taught. When I was in school in the 80's and 90's we hardly ever learned science or social studies. There is just not enough time in the day. Especially since a majority of parents do not teach their kids the basics. Counting, letters, etc etc. The common mentality seems to be "that's what teachers are for." Since so many kids come in not knowing the difference between letters and numbers, there just isn't enough time to get to the fun stuff (science history) So many of our students are never read to at home. Books are non existent in a lot of households. Reading simple cat in the hat books are so important. It introduced children to words, cadence etc. So important.
The article gives examples from a single unnamed source. For all I know it was entirely made up. They aren't specific enough for me to believe that there actually was a teacher interviewed. Also, I don't really understand what indoctrination the author is taking about. Is it that petroleum and oil spills are bad? Is it that textbooks are not being given out since classes are online now? What is she talking about?
I have never witnessed a teacher indoctrinating kids. Does it happen? I'm sure it does. I've talked numerous times about hunting and conservation. Is that indoctrination? It has nothing to do with behavioral issues....
I would grade the article a "C+" just because she gave an attempt lol. But I'm sure she would rather me give her an "F" since she tried to argue that teachers are giving kids credit for wrong answers.
 
And.......
Integrated curriculum has nothing to do with indoctrination or taking away subjects.
All integrated learning is, in my experiences, is integrating subjects together.
For example, you could integrate the curriculum by using your science handout as the reading material for the day. Using the science lab numbers you recorded as the math assignment.... Integrating two subjects together to make real life connections.
I really feel that the author of this article doesn't know WTH she's talking about. It is more of a click-bait article designed to generate emotional reactions from people who don't have a clue about the subject but want to argue that the country is going to hell fl by some hidden agenda.
 

Click-a-Pic ... Details & Bigger Photos
Back
Top Bottom