I, too, have never been a fan of Simmons. I've never owned one myself, but I know a number of people who have and most have had problems with them. However, two years ago, I bought a new rifle for my son: a Winchester Model 70 Custom Compact in 7mm-08- not a cheap rifle. I told the guy who owns a local sporting goods store that I wanted to get a decent scope for the rifle, but that I didn't want to spend another $300-$400 for it. He strongly recommended a new scope, the Simmons Whitetail Expedition, and said that he had put one on one of his rifles and loved it. He ordered a 1.5-6x in for me on approval. When it came in, I put it on a blank stock with rubber mounts and took it outside. I was so impressed with it that I bought it. (The scopes on all my own rifles are Leupold Vari-X IIIs.) It has ALT (aspherical lens technology), so it's exceptionally crisp and clear from edge to edge and has dependable adjustments and repeatable accuracy; we've had no problems with it whatsoever. Best of all, I got a great deal on it - $139 (it retails for about $200). They also make a 3-9x, 4-12x, and a 6-18x in the Whitetail Expedition series, and they're considerably less than other scopes of comparable quality. (Can't believe I'm endorsing a Simmons scope, but if you're looking for value, I don't think you'll be disappointed.)