M
muskrat
Guest
http://www.billingsgazette.com/inde...s/2004/07/24/build/state/80-hunting-rules.inc
Nonresidents may fight hunting rules
Associated Press
BOZEMAN (AP) - A federal judge's ruling in an Arizona case involving caps on nonresident hunters and the fees they must pay may affect similar regulations in Montana, a state wildlife agency attorney says.
Montana will either have to change its big game hunting regulations or face an inevitable lawsuit from nonresident hunters disgruntled by high fees and limits on the number of licenses available, said Tom Lane of the Department of Fish, Wildlife and Parks.
Reacting to a ruling striking down Arizona's 10 percent cap on nonresident elk and deer licenses, Lane told the Bozeman Daily Chronicle that the same or similar plaintiffs will challenge Montana's rules.
The Arizona plaintiffs already have visited Montana officials, Lane said, but they stopped short of saying they would sue. They specifically suggested Montana change the way it issues big game licenses, he said.
U.S. District Judge Robert Broomfield ruled July 13 that by limiting nonresidents to 10 percent of available licenses, Arizona violated the commerce clause of the U.S. Constitution.
A commercial hunter from New Mexico sued the Arizona Fish and Game Department. He said the state's rules deprived him of an equal opportunity to obtain elk and deer heads and antlers, which can be worth thousands of dollars to collectors, and Broomfield agreed.
Lane said Montana legislators could pass a law next session making it illegal for anyone to sell the hide, head or antlers of a game animal, and that could address the commerce issue of the Arizona case.
Like Arizona, Montana has a quota for nonresident elk and deer licenses, currently 11,500. This year, 14,897 people applied.
One important difference in Montana is that any nonresident can avoid the quota by paying a higher fee for a guaranteed-issue tag, Lane said. That means nonresidents would pay $877, or 55 times the $16 resident elk license fee, for a guaranteed tag. Nonresident hunters can enter a drawing and pay $590 for an elk license, still 37 times as much as a resident pays.
www.parchedmuskrat.com
Nonresidents may fight hunting rules
Associated Press
BOZEMAN (AP) - A federal judge's ruling in an Arizona case involving caps on nonresident hunters and the fees they must pay may affect similar regulations in Montana, a state wildlife agency attorney says.
Montana will either have to change its big game hunting regulations or face an inevitable lawsuit from nonresident hunters disgruntled by high fees and limits on the number of licenses available, said Tom Lane of the Department of Fish, Wildlife and Parks.
Reacting to a ruling striking down Arizona's 10 percent cap on nonresident elk and deer licenses, Lane told the Bozeman Daily Chronicle that the same or similar plaintiffs will challenge Montana's rules.
The Arizona plaintiffs already have visited Montana officials, Lane said, but they stopped short of saying they would sue. They specifically suggested Montana change the way it issues big game licenses, he said.
U.S. District Judge Robert Broomfield ruled July 13 that by limiting nonresidents to 10 percent of available licenses, Arizona violated the commerce clause of the U.S. Constitution.
A commercial hunter from New Mexico sued the Arizona Fish and Game Department. He said the state's rules deprived him of an equal opportunity to obtain elk and deer heads and antlers, which can be worth thousands of dollars to collectors, and Broomfield agreed.
Lane said Montana legislators could pass a law next session making it illegal for anyone to sell the hide, head or antlers of a game animal, and that could address the commerce issue of the Arizona case.
Like Arizona, Montana has a quota for nonresident elk and deer licenses, currently 11,500. This year, 14,897 people applied.
One important difference in Montana is that any nonresident can avoid the quota by paying a higher fee for a guaranteed-issue tag, Lane said. That means nonresidents would pay $877, or 55 times the $16 resident elk license fee, for a guaranteed tag. Nonresident hunters can enter a drawing and pay $590 for an elk license, still 37 times as much as a resident pays.
www.parchedmuskrat.com
