Flip a coin...same quality, same amount of hunters, etc.
The problem with both is that everyone hunts one or the other, and everyone has a pocket full of tags. Most cant shoot for chit and the pronghorn get skittish. Combined with the average hunter out there having a phobia of using glass and boots. The preferred hunting method by a lot of the NR crowd is drive every road that's open, hop out and blaze away every time a pronghorn is within 500-600 yards of the road. Many times, they like to film their "hunts" out there too.
It would be nice if about 80% of the roads were closed in both HMA's. Either that or make one or the other primarily walk-in only. The hunt quality has gone to complete crap in that unit.