I have spent very little time on the Henry's, I have killed big bucks, I have miss big bucks, I have passed on big bucks.
With all that being said, I cannot say either way what would happen until I was put in that situation. Multiple factors would play into my decision, (i.e. How far into the hunt, previous scouting, etc.) I consider myself a trophy hunter, I have eaten many tags, and without a doubt many things would sway my opinion. I don't only look at the animal, most times the trophy is in the memories.
I can promise you, that if my son or daughter were with me, and that buck was in range and they wanted me to shoot it...... an arrow would be flying his direction.