Interestingly, even though this buck appears to be a taller racked buck than the other, he doesn't appeal as much to me as the other buck. Although it's hard to tell from the angle of the pictures, this deer doesn't appear to be as old of a buck as the other buck. He just doesn't have that old sway backed looked that truly mature deer tend to have.
Also, although technically you could say he has a four point frame, the left side is more of a three point frame with a small "inline" point at the end of the G2. It just leaves kind of a spindly look to him in my opinion. With that said, he appears to be the type of deer that, with a few more years of growth, could turn into something special. You never know what those odd antler configurations will turn into given some time.
If there is any chance this deer might make it through the hunting season, I say give him a couple more years to grow. By the time he is as old as the other buck, he could be a real dandy non-typical.
Wildman
"Hoss you convinced me what day are we packing up and leaving this Mormon hell hole for California?"- coondog 5/13/15