Thanks for taking the time to reply and share your hunt report. I was also in GMU 8 during the archery elk hunt as my son had drawn a tag (resident, 9 points IIRC), it was his 2nd choice on his application.
We hunted for a total of 9 days and in that time only encountered hunters in the field with a bow actually hunting twice. We did cross paths with several hunters that were road hunting, mostly on roads that were closed to motorized vehicles. I guess these hunters don't bother with maps and figure if the road isn't marked with a 4x8 sign stating DO NOT ENTER, or has a tire track on it, then it's ok to drive on the road into the forested areas where other hunters have made the effort to pack into for the day. Oh well, that's public lands hunting; unfortunately all too familiar to many of us who hunt Arizona's public lands.
I wish the Forest Service had the personnel and the funds(they state they don't)to actual put signs on ALL the closed roads and then have reasonable enforcement patrolling to discourage those looking for the "roads easier traveled" so those doing it lawfully on foot are not disturbed by the rule breakers.
We found that the bulls were not nearly as vocal as most elk rut hunting archers would have hoped. I believe we gave it a solid effort. My son had opportunities at three different bulls I coaxed into reasonable archery shot range (furthest was 37 yards); sometimes it's just a bit tougher with a beginning bowhunter, no matter how much they practiced shooting throughout the year. It's the little things: knowing how to position for a shot setup, knowing when it's time to put away the rangefinder, knowing when to draw, and knowing when to loose an arrow comes with experience. He will be a better hunter in the future for the experience we shared on this hunt. We camped in a secluded spot away from other folks, ate well, enjoyed our time together, heard some elk sing their September Songs and felt adrenaline-fueled thumping hearts as bulls came into bow range. I'd say we had a successful hunt and look forward to the next permit, just hopefully not such a long wait between tags!