RELH, i think he means the difference between a 20" barrel and a 16 1/2". i don't think he meant to cut off the 16 1/2". there is also a minimum overall length for at least shotguns, too. from what i remember, that is what got weaver. the gun was legal when he bought it and he took the kick pad off or some deal, and then it was too short overall. there were some other deals about sawing off a barrell too, but it seems the gun he got cited over originally, was too short overall. i think. hell, that was a couple years ago and i'm gettin' old. i do know one thing, he didn't do anything to deserve what he got. but that's another story. also, the minimum barrel length for rifles is 16" and shotguns is 18". some of the old trapper model winchesters 94's and 92's just had 14 or 15 inch barrels. they are grandfathered.