The cove area behind mustang campground wraps around to an area called dutch john draw. Those coves are loaded with lots of smallies and are an easy walk with plenty of bass to catch. I always used plastic, worms, tubes, twisters in any colors that resemble a motor oil type color. If you're are familiar with a drop shot rig it would work well. Wacky style as mentioned by someone earlier would also work well. On the lake, any cove with a stream emptying into the lake can be fished with light tackle, split shot and a worm, with great success. Renting fishing boats at the marina could be an option if you wanted to troll or fish under the cart creek bridge. There are some great areas to troll not far from the marina. The lake is full of fish, as a kid, I used to work at the marina every summer. I would drift a night cralwer under the docks during the day and would always catch fish under the marina. Also, there are lots of little streams full of trout, with a bucket of worms you could catch lots of brookies. I actually lived in Dutch John as a kid and moved just after high school. I was there last summer and everything was pretty much the same as I had left it. We caught a bunch of browns on the river and had a great time. You can out fish the fly fishermen if you know what to use. If you have any specific questions please Pm me. Thanks