LAST EDITED ON May-01-10 AT 09:37AM (MST)[p]If you are hunting thicker cover for elk and deer, then I would say the Zen Ray 7x36 or 8x43 ED2 for the greater FOV and DOF. For more open country, go with the 10x43ED2. Great glass to fit your budget.
To save a few $, CameraLand is advertising demo ED (not ED2) for 300 bucks, and doubt you could tell any diff from new.
I have compared my pair of 8x43ED (not ED2) to 8.5x42EL and found the ELs to have about a 1 block advantage on a resolution chart. Both blew the Monarchs and Vipers away. I and another also slightly preferred the optics of the Zens to the Vortex Razors. Razors and ELS had better fit and finish than the Zens, especially with the eye-cups in terms of tightness/tolerance of adjustment.
I recently got a pair Zen 7x36ED2 and compared them to a friends 8.5x32ELs one evening after sunset, resting on a porch rail and looking at shingles and a pine tree 200 yards away. The Zens appeared brighter and with more contrast. Resolution was slightly in favor to the EL. I did not do a check of edge-to-edge or flatness of field.
I have compared the 8x43ED to a pair of 10x42SLC, and liked the Zens better in terms of contrast, color cast and slightly sharper in the center.
$400 for Zen ED2s, or $2400 for ELs? I'd pocket the extra 2 grand and go on a hunt.
I have not looked through a pair, but for a little more ching, the Leupold GR have a little better reports. Cabelas have them on sale for $699, same as SWFA, and there is also a $100 mail-in rebate. Final $599 may be above your budget though.
Doug~RR
You are welcome to visit my Photo Gallery here
http://dougkoepsel.smugmug.com/