Okay, we can put this to rest. I was with bigoltom when he got these pics, we were scouting for my hunt.
I shot the one on the left opening morning. He scored 182 and some change. I watched the one on the right through my scope for about 15-20 minutes after I killed mine. I think hes a little better than the picture lets on.
Yes, I think I shot the smaller of the 2 so I'm sticking with my low to mid 190's guess with the buck on the right.
P.S., the buck on the left was only 23 1/2" wide, good mass and long points.
Is that ethical?