NVBighorn, you almost nailed it down, I think.
No question, Faith Hill is totally beautiful lady in a classic, generic, clean all-American covergirl way. But even when she cut off all that hair, to me, she had basically the same look as she always has had. Beautiful but pretty darn BORING............
Shania, on the other hand, continues to be an interesting, suprising beauty. Look back at her first videos and tell me she didn't have that clean all-American (OK, all-Candadian) look for the longest time. Then the wardrobe started changing. Then the makeup. Here in this video, she's trying some kinda gothic look. Point is, she changes her look more often than anyone out there and I think that adds some intrigue to her, some spice. And I dunno about you, but I kinda like that about Shania. Not to mention her backwoods background, rags to riches story and that she's the babe that put n a completely new sound to country music, and got a lot more folks both listening and singing pop country. I appreciate her for the entire package, not just the new look that she's trying out today or tomorrow.........
Huntsonora and the rest of you B&C counters; to each their own of course... but I'd have to score Faith in the typical category, net 185, and Shania mores as a non-typical 240. But that's just me....