After one of our typical debates, Graybeard and I still feel differently on this one. Of course we usually do! You see, I'm usually right, but he just won't admit it. LOL Just kidding Steve!!
Ok, so he called me today and we began this discussion. He stated to me his theory, which is posted above. However, I have a different theory.
I believe that "deer" get split ears because of the very low blood flow in the thin cartilage near the outside edges of the ears. In addition, during the summer months when their hair is thinnest, many deer will wear much of the hair off the ends of their ears feeding in thick brush. Thus, compounding the problem, because the hair no longer protects the ears from the heat of the sun and the brush.
Splits in ears happen not only to bucks, but also to does, so the theory of it occurring as a result of a fight, doesn't fly in my opinion.
And, because ears move so freely, I think it would be very difficult for the antler tine of another deer to poke through a deer ear. And, the splits are usually only an inch or so long. If these injuries were occurring as a result of fights, we should see a greater number of 4-5 inch splits and more eyes poked out.
Bottom line, I say low blood flow in the thin cartilage.
What do you all think?
If you don't agree with me, you're banned!! LOL Just kidding!
Brian Latturner
MonsterMuleys.com