Of the two you mentioned, neither. I'm with Gator. It costs less in the long run to to spend $1,500 on a used top end spotter, including interest, than it does to buy a $250 spotter, then a $600 spotter, then a $1,000 spotter only to end up buying the $1,500 spotter 4 years later at a higher price. I know, I have a $1,500 spotter I've invested $3,000 after working my way up to it. I bought my Swaroski spotter on sale at Bass Pro and had a 30% off grand opening coupon. Deals can be had if you shop around and your spotter will last many years if you care for it.