I think that it is a personal decision. If I were to scout out a trophy buck or an area that produces trophy animals I wouldn't tell the whole world. I've kicked myself in the butt a hundred times for telling people my favorite fishing hotspot or hunting honey hole and I still catch myself telling people too much info. Its just the way I am.(A bigmouth). I always tell myself that I'm not telling anybody but I always do. But I'm getting better.
I used to sink Christmass trees in ponds in Florida and nobody ever wanted to help. Boy it sure turned unproductive water into Bass havens. Then I would take one person with me and the next thing you know everybody knew about it. Thats it! Now I'm pissed off again. Hell no, I ain't tellin' nobody nothin' ever again.
(Sorry, kinda lost it there.) Fatrooster.