IMPRESSIVE ALBERTA TYPICAL
- Thread starter eldorado
- Start date
S
springbear
Guest
I thought when that buck went to the pannel, they called the G2 and 3 a common base and it did not beat out jhonsons buck.
I could be wrong, it is still one of the most empressive typicals ever.
I could be wrong, it is still one of the most empressive typicals ever.
completesportsman
Long Time Member
- Messages
- 3,508
I think the scoring comment above is correct if I remember right. I saw this buck at a show a year of so after it was taken.
I think P&Y wanted to score it as a non-typ, Zaft thinking he had a new world record typical was upset and withdrew it all together from the P&Y book......if I remember correctly.
I think P&Y wanted to score it as a non-typ, Zaft thinking he had a new world record typical was upset and withdrew it all together from the P&Y book......if I remember correctly.
M
me_rob2011
Guest
W
wooly
Guest
Beautiful!!
T
TOOTHandTINE
Guest
You guys are correct, the deemed the g2,g3 as acommon base point, which took this almost world record status buck down to a 170 2/8 typical.
There was alot of strange things happening with the panel, that Wayne pulled it. B&C ask to score it properly, because they didn'tbelieve that P&Y had made the correct decision.
I know P&Y can some strange choices.
I have seen the common point that they refer to, and they made the wrong decision. I also know of deer that actually have common bases that they have entered that shouldn't have been.
Unfortunately, the buck gets punished the most, denying it, the recognition that it deserves, not the is/isn't everyone discusses.
There was alot of strange things happening with the panel, that Wayne pulled it. B&C ask to score it properly, because they didn'tbelieve that P&Y had made the correct decision.
I know P&Y can some strange choices.
I have seen the common point that they refer to, and they made the wrong decision. I also know of deer that actually have common bases that they have entered that shouldn't have been.
Unfortunately, the buck gets punished the most, denying it, the recognition that it deserves, not the is/isn't everyone discusses.
H
hunt4130
Guest
thats a pretty deer!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
W
Waterdogs
Guest
I think I would have to let that one walk. I would be shacking to much to get a shot. That is an amazing animal. Do not know the story but he is a great deer. If he wasn't baited or pen raised on a private ranch that makes him even cooler. I am not a P&Y or B&C guy my friends are all about that crap. I know big when I see it and I think their scoring system is kinda stupid.
treedagain
Long Time Member
- Messages
- 6,522
great buck
S
SaskJack
Guest
>I think I would have to
>let that one walk. I
>would be shacking to much
>to get a shot. That
>is an amazing animal. Do
>not know the story but
>he is a great deer.
>If he wasn't baited or
>pen raised on a private
>ranch that makes him even
>cooler. I am not a
>P&Y or B&C guy my
>friends are all about that
>crap. I know big when
>I see it and I
>think their scoring system is
>kinda stupid.
There are very few game ranch's in Canada. 99.9% of game taken is free range on public or private land.
>let that one walk. I
>would be shacking to much
>to get a shot. That
>is an amazing animal. Do
>not know the story but
>he is a great deer.
>If he wasn't baited or
>pen raised on a private
>ranch that makes him even
>cooler. I am not a
>P&Y or B&C guy my
>friends are all about that
>crap. I know big when
>I see it and I
>think their scoring system is
>kinda stupid.
There are very few game ranch's in Canada. 99.9% of game taken is free range on public or private land.
Whitetail Hunting Guides & Outfitters
Whitetail Pros Guide Service
Southern Iowa and Missouri Private Land Whitetail Hunts. Rifle, Archery, Muzzleloader.
Antler Creek Whitetails
Archery hunt in Northeast Kansas. Rut and pre-rut, hunting from treestands and blinds.