We took two bucks the 1st year. One was a 4 point with good mass but it had weak forks and only about 23 inches wide. The other buck was a buck we had found during the summer and he scored in the 180's somewhere...don't remember exactly. Not a real strong main frame, only about 24 inches wide, but he had split cheaters coming out both sides and then a 3rd cheater on one side. Not the biggest buck in the world, but definatley a trophy in my mind. My dad missed the biggest buck we saw opening morning. He was a really nice four point, with deep forks, nice mass, and guard horns. I'd guess him around 27 to 28 inches wide.
The next year we had one tag and killed a good four point...biggest buck we saw. He's not particularly wide, 24 inches, but he has good tine length, guard horns, and mass. I don't know how to score them, but I'd put him in the low 170's at best. Would have held out for a better buck, but we were concerned about getting our rig out. Turns out we just barely made it.