I've shot with a biscuit for the last year and hunted hogs with it. For close in shooting, I don't think it can be topped. The complete containment of the arrow is outstanding, particuarly for hunting from a treestand or blind. I've never had any issues with the noise of Gold Tips through it. I hunt with two bows (bowtech allegiances), one for spot and stalk hunting and one for stand hunting around water holes. For the stand hunting, or any hunting out to 40yds or so, the biscuit is first rate. For longer shooting, I've become acutely aware of how much more sensitive the rest is to slight changes in form/follow through. I think it is capable of as much accuracy--I just can't shoot as good of groups all the time when compared to a drop away or fingers. As a result, for my spot and stalk hunting, I use a bow with a drop away because I am getting more consistent accuracy beyond 40 yds. If you think you are not going to be shooting farther, or your form is more consistent, it may well be the perfect rest for you! I'd love to see someone with a mechanical shooter test the biscuit at long range and compare accuracy to other rests.