LAST EDITED ON Aug-04-09 AT 11:29PM (MST)[p]
LAST EDITED ON Aug-04-09 AT 11:20?PM (MST)
I have to admit, I cringed when I saw the picture of the bivy hunter, my preferred style of hunting by the way, dressed in jeans with bad weather looming and snow in the background.
Can it be done, yea, sure but why is my question and I would disagree that that is how most people hunted prior to Gore-Tex in that kind of weather. Wool was the dominate foul/cold weather fabric of choice. Waxed or oiled natural fibers were used mostly by mountaineers but they were purpose built and very dense mostly to protect against wind. They were usually wearing wool underneathe. And that is what they were wearing because that is all they had. Todays hardcore outdoormen are not wearing Wranglers EDIT in those kinds of conditions.
The mountaineers bible, Freedom Of The Hills, says this about cotton. "Cotton-loses its insulating qualities when wet, absorbs many times its own weight in water, and generally takes a long time to dry. Because of these characteristics it is dangerous to rely on cotton for warmth. Cotton plays a common role is many hypothermia deaths."
Cotton kills is the catch phrase in the business and the experts teach against its use in the back country where cool or cold temps and bad weather is a possibility and you have no solid bail out options. Most people don't have the chops to pull it off. If you have, you have either been lucky or you are really good and my bet is that if you are that good you wouldn't be wearing cotton.
I have hauled a fair amount of dead bodies out of the central Arizona mountains that were clad in jeans, jeans jackets and cotton sweatshirts in that same kind of weather or better. But again my question is why take that kind of a gamble when there are so many other better alternatives available? What is it about denim that makes it worth thumbing your nose at conventional wisdom and modern technology?
The other question I have is, if you are bivy hunting with a 2000 ci pack, space is a premium. So, why carry a set of rain gear during bad weather in your pack? Why not wear it and eliminate the jeans altogether?
I think I could do what you described with that pack in those conditions but I have a higher level of training and experience then most EDIT not to mention the best gear money can buy and I would consider it out there on the ragged edge and risky. I certainly wouldn't be wearing any cotton.
Wade
www.HardcoreOutdoor.com