Boy, thats a tough one! I loved my Mathews....had it for three years and never shot a bow better than I shot that, yet here I am on the "good side of archery" with a Hoyt again......so you never know what can happen. But good habits die hard, and I've got a pretty tight thing going with my 5 iron!
I chronographed my Alpha Max at 300 fps set up for hunting. That was with a 375 grain arrow and the bow set at 71 - 72 lbs. My Mathews was giving me 275 fps with the same set up, so there's no doubt that this Hoyt is faster. I just havent shot it enough yet to decide of it's smoother than the Mathews. Of course I know the AlphaMax is shorter and lighter, but I still am anxious to see how smooth it shoots compared with my old Mathews. Everything I've heard has been good though. Good to hear from you.