Which one?

[MountainSqwabler]

I thought it would be fun since i haven't found a post like this.

Which one would you rather shoot? Which one would have more "trophy" reward for you, not just meat.

 

[elkassassin]

I Guess The Whitetail For Me Since I Don't Have That Yet!

 

[tailchasers]

The 150" WT has eluded me in life to date even though I have and my fair share of opportunities. Buck fever is a SOB for some people. Guess I am some people.

 

[nfh]

150 whitey . Chased 2 all through archery. Freakin nocturnal suckers outsmarted all month

 

[antlerradar]

Not even close, a 180 mule deer is B&C awards, the other are far short. Should be a 160 whitetail, 360 elk and an 80 inch Pronghorn for comparable size.

 

[buckspotter7]

Or lower mule deer to 160. No contest 180 mule deer

 

[MountainSqwabler]

Was actually supposed to be 170" muley but I fat fingered and can't find how to change that one.

 

[antlerradar]

Was actually supposed to be 170" muley but I fat fingered and can't find how to change that one.

At a 170 mule deer I am passing on all of them.

 

[Gadjet]

I feel like this isn't a very even comparison. But I would have to go with the 330 bull.

 

[wweaver79]

180 mule deer all day for me. Have a couple 150 WT and the others.

 

[Tristate]

180 muley

 

[The_Coloradoboy]

150 inch whitey for me

 

[Old Cowboy]

180 Muleys are kinda hard to find unless they're in the rut. I hunted muleys about 65 years and killed a few of them but I never hunted the rut

 

[coloradoman]

150 inch whitey for me

Agreed!
I have 180” muleys and 330 elk.

 

[Stillwater165]

Well I’ve got the rest, but I sure don’t have any 170 muleys …… maybe some day !

 

[Focoelkman]

It’s a monster Muley site , going with a big haas! 180 plus
I’ve froze my ash off in tree stands growin up.