Well, from being from Washington, I'd take either one of them fair chase and be very happy. I think I would rather shoot the first as he was a hawg in size, and the most mature. I believe the other one will grow a bit more next year, but will probably still be a three point. His "Daddy" whom I probably saw about 3 years ago was a super hawg three point that was incredible and kicked butt on both. His frame was very similiar proportioned, but about 3 times the mass with lots of moss, and of course a bit wider and very much taller. I'll see if I can drum up a pic.