So your theory is that since we are so far in debt more debt will cure the problems. That does nothing to solve the structural problems of the auto industry it just moves us further into debt. You don't like borrowing from China but where do you thing the auto bailout money is going to come from?
Some company would purchase assets out of bankruptcy or a new company would be formed or the old company would be reformed. That is just a fact, now whether or not the falter is another story. Chrysler is an example of a company that should probably be either absorbed or shut down or sold off to a more competent owner.
I don't want the UAW workers to lose their jobs but that is the reality of the situation. I am not against the workers in the UAW I am against their leadership, their leadership is as guilty as the CEO's when it comes to being over paid and under performing. But here in the real world when one works for a business that is struggling the workers lose their jobs, that is just reality. Now the UAW is saying that their jobs are more important then my job or your job and anyone else jobs because so many rely on the revenue these jobs create. Well I am sorry but spending taxpayer money to subsidize these jobs and taking that money from many, many taxpayers who are making less is immoral and bad public policy. Perhaps it is because you have no children that you see this a necessary use of taxpayer dollars?
Who want to buy a car from a bankrupt company, I don't really care about that because right now not many people want to buy a car from an uncompetitive company. Explain how this money is going to make these companies compete better. All their legacy costs remain in place as do all their current costs for materials and components. This is just prolonging the inevitable.
What Buffet is saying is that he would force a deal just like a deal he would make if he were buying a company. He believes bankruptcy is wasteful I guess that is his opinion. In addition he states that 3 million jobs won't be lost, that only the president of the U.S. can achieve this and that if you don't have a viable business plan that makes sense we will be giving money every year to these companies. He says there are only two ways to go either bankruptcy or a bailout, and he argues for a bailout. Here is his interview.
http://dahhuilaudavid.blogspot.com/2008/11/fox-business-warren-buffett-on-auto.html
Again find the Constitutional basis for the President of the U.S. to be making such a deal. Buffet can make business sense out of such a deal. Also ask yourself this question: Why isn't he putting his billion into such a deal? He is famous for buying undervalued companies, he hasn't made major purchases of auto companies stocks, so he has no skin in the game. Why do you suppose that is?
Can you find an Auto Company Stock in the holding of Berkshire-Hathaway? Berkshire Hathaway Inc holdings, (NYSE: BRK-A)for the Quarter ended on June 30, 2008
-American Express Co. (NYSE: AXP) over 151.6 million shares.
-Anheuser Busch Cos. Inc. (NYSE: BUD) taken to under 15 million shares from over 35 million shares on last report
-Bank of America Corp. (NYSE: BAC) 9.1 million shares
-Burlington Northern Santa Fe (NYSE: BNI) 63,785,418 shares
-Carmax Inc. (NYSE: KMX) 21.3 million shares
-Coca Cola (NYSE: KO) roughly 200 million shares
-Comcast (NASDAQ: CMCSA) 12 million shares
-Comdisco Holdings (CDCO) over 1.5 million shares
-Costco Wholesale (NASDAQ: COST) 5.254 million shares
-Gannett Co. (NYSE: GCI) 3.447 million shares
-General Electric Corp. (NYSE: GE) 7.777 million shares
-GlaxoSmithkline (NYSE: GSK) 1.51 million shares
-Home Depot Inc. (NYSE: HD) 4,181,000 shares
-Ingersoll-Rand (NYSE: IR) 5,636,600 shares
-Iron Mountain (NYSE: IRM) 3,372,200 shares
-Johnson & Johnson (NYSE: JNJ) listed about 61.75 million shares in multiple lots
-Kraft Foods (NYSE: KFT) listed about 138.3 million shares in multiple lots
-Lowes Companies (NYSE: LOW) 7 million shares
-M&T Bank Corp. (NYSE: MTB) 6.71 million shares
-Moody's (NYSE: MCO) 48 million shares
-Nike Inc. (NYSE: NKE) 7.641 million shares
-Norfolk Southern (NYSE: NSC) 1.933 million shares
-NRG Energy (NYSE: NRG) 3.238 million shares
-Procter & Gamble (NYSE: PG) more than 105.8 million shares
-Sanofi Aventis (NYSE: SNY) more than 3.9 million shares
-Sun Trust Bank (NYSE: STI) more than 3.2 million shares
-Torchmark Corp. (NYSE: TMK) more than 3.51 million shares in multiple lots
-US Bancorp (NYSE: USB) more than 68 million shares in multiple lots
-USG Corp. (NYSE: USG) 17.07 million shares
U-nion Pacific Corp. (NYSE: UNP) 8.9 million shares
-United Parcel Service (NYSE: UPS) 1.429 million shares
-WABCO Holdings (NYSE: WBC) 2.7 million shares
-Wal-Mart Stores inc. (NYSE: WMT) over 19.9 million shares in multiple lots
-Washington Post (NYSE: WPO) over 1.72 million shares in multiple lots
-Wells Fargo (NYSE: WFC) over 290 million shares in multiple lots
-Wellpoint Inc. (NYSE: WLP) 4.8 million shares
-Wesco Financial Corp. (NYSE: WSC) 5.7 million shares
Nemont